News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Why giving away the software might be the best solution

We’re considering differentiating our product in the one way that really makes sense for us: giving it away.

The desktop version would be completely free: - fully customizable, - local-first, - and with the ability to plug in your own AI API keys. ... No forced cloud, no lock-in.

Our thinking is that most competitors can’t or won’t do this. Instead of monetizing access to the core product, we’d grow through optional plug-and-play integrations (20% markup), plus collaboration and cloud features for teams.

The goal is simple: we want people to actually use the software.

Genuinely curious what HN thinks... Is this something you’d use? Is this a sane model, or a terrible idea?

( 2 comments | 2 points | on HN )
Re:Why giving away the software might be the best solution by melvinroest on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @07:57AM (#46885283)
What I know from my marketing experience is this: tools are much better forms of content marketing than content itself is. It's more unique, more novel, less rehashed and so on. But this only makes sense if you can then offer a service behind the tool.

If I understand it correctly, you are betting that you can basically do some implementation consulting. That could work. It depends on who comes on your path.

In your case, what you could also do is offer lifetime access for free but only for a limited time. Be upfront that it is a marketing thing. Also be upfront that if you happen to become a billion dollar business that they'd still have free access.

I'm going to do something similar-ish. I'm currently building a course for people to learn SQL at a data analyst level. I'm going to offer it for free. I think people should just know SQL, period. The idea is also that it will be a marketing tool for other courses or services that I'll develop that are related to that space. I'm not sure where I want to go yet since I'm just focusing on the SQL course for now. But I know it can work and I find it nice to think that I'll help the world be better at SQL for free, regardless of whether they need any service from me or not.

And I know there are other free SQL courses out there. A good one is here [1]. But I'll be honest, I still paid for SQL courses despite having seen that. So I'm addressing those pain points. It's a good SQL guide, but it didn't wet my appetite to learn it and I still went the paid route. Also, it's more comprehensive, a data analyst doesn't need to know certain sections.

Anyways, that's my 2 cents and context for how I came about these thoughts. I hope it helps.

[1] https://gvwilson.github.io/querynomicon/

Re:Why giving away the software might be the best solution by compressedgas on Wednesday February 04, 2026 @08:27PM (#46894424)
That's what Obsidian did.