Re:Mobile carriers can get your GPS location
by newzino on Sunday February 01, 2026 @11:17AM
(#46847184)
Carriers knowing your approximate location from tower attachment is expected. What’s surprising (to a lot of people) is the separate, control-plane “positioning” path where the network can ask the handset for its own GNSS fix (meter-level), and the phone can respond without this being part of the normal OS location permission model.
That’s the uncomfortable bit: it’s not “GPS broadcasts your location” (GNSS is passive), it’s the baseband/network stack can be prompted to send a precise fix. And because it lives in the modem/control plane, it’s basically invisible to users and hard to audit.
If this capability exists for emergency location, fine—but then it should be locked to emergency sessions, logged, and auditable. A user-visible “limit precise location to carrier” toggle that still allows emergency sharing is exactly the shape of the right fix: restrict default sharing + make non-emergency use provable and accountable.
That’s the uncomfortable bit: it’s not “GPS broadcasts your location” (GNSS is passive), it’s the baseband/network stack can be prompted to send a precise fix. And because it lives in the modem/control plane, it’s basically invisible to users and hard to audit.
If this capability exists for emergency location, fine—but then it should be locked to emergency sessions, logged, and auditable. A user-visible “limit precise location to carrier” toggle that still allows emergency sharing is exactly the shape of the right fix: restrict default sharing + make non-emergency use provable and accountable.