Re:Mobile carriers can get your GPS location
by cpncrunch on Saturday January 31, 2026 @09:57PM
(#46843212)
So how should it work?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mobile carriers can get your GPS location
by anonymous908213 on Saturday January 31, 2026 @11:55PM
(#46843732)
The government has absolutely zero right to know the exact location of an individual down to ~1m precision at all times. The way it should work is that there is a law (and there is a UN charter, ie. it's already international law) stating privacy is a human right and they do not have the ability to compel this information, ever, even if someone is suspected of a crime. Warrants are not a free pass to violate any and all laws because a judge says so. There is a very specific scope of what warrants are allowed for, and this case should not be one of them.
Even if you trust your current government, this power is so easily abused once you have a system in place for it that you are basically condemning every future "enemy of the state" to a regime to death, all the moreso as phones become increasingly strictly tied to identity and necessary to access basic services in society.
Re:Mobile carriers can get your GPS location
by p-e-w on Saturday January 31, 2026 @11:17PM
(#46843561)
With fundamental rules, applicable to all situations, limiting what information courts can demand. There are things so private that they should be out of reach of the state regardless of what justification someone can come up with.