News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private by JasonADrury on Saturday January 31, 2026 @04:35PM (#46841103)
>Expalin how you detect a branched/flaged sendKey (or whatever it would be called) call in the compiled WhatsApp iOS app?

Vastly easier than spotting a clever bugdoor in the source code of said app.

Re:US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private by refulgentis on Saturday January 31, 2026 @04:39PM (#46841129)
Putting it all on the table: do you agree with the claim that binary analysis is just as good as source code analysis?
Re:US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private by JasonADrury on Saturday January 31, 2026 @04:40PM (#46841149)
Binary analysis is vastly better than source code analysis, reliably detecting bugdoors via source code analysis tends to require an unrealistically deep knowledge of compiler behavior.
Re:US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private by anonymars on Saturday January 31, 2026 @05:37PM (#46841619)
Empirically it doesn't look like there's a meaningful difference, does it?

Not having the source code hasn't stopped people from finding exploits in Windows (or even hardware attacks like Spectre or Meltdown). Having source code didn't protect against Heartbleed or log4j

I'd conclude it comes down to security culture (look how things changed after the Trustworthy Computing initiative, or OpenSSL vs LibreSSL) and "how many people are looking" -- in that sense, maybe "many eyes [do] make bugs shallow" but it doesn't seem like "source code availability" is the deciding factor. Rather, "what are the incentives" -- both on the internal development side and the external attacker side

Re:US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private by tptacek on Saturday January 31, 2026 @04:57PM (#46841311)
I don't agree with "vastly better" but its arguable both in the direction and magnitude. I don't think you could plausibly argue that binary analysis is "vastly harder".
Re:US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private by TZubiri on Saturday January 31, 2026 @04:44PM (#46841193)
Nono, analyzing binaries is harder.

But it's still possible. And analyzing source code is still hard.