Re:Map of CPAN - The Movie
by delinka on Monday October 22, 2012 @08:37AM
(#4682844)
I'd enjoy a week with some tools to make visualizations like this. Looks cool, but what is it telling me?
- Why is there blue space between segments?
- Why do the colored (non-blue) segments crawl around instead of growing/shrinking?
- If any segment actually changes size, I can't tell because of the crawl
- If the crawling is due to "continental drift," there's not an obvious path that the flow takes. I can see that it starts in the upper left corner, but when I notice that the path squiggles around, I have to study it for far too long to figure out where the bits are headed.
Re:Map of CPAN - The Movie
by natep on Monday October 22, 2012 @08:57AM
(#4682899)
To address questions 2-4, it's a space-filling curve [1], or basically an easy way to take a line and fill a 2D space. So when a single name is added to a namespace at the beginning of the curve, that blob gets bigger, and every other blob moves 'right'. Once you stare at it a while, you can see that every blob moves along the same path, and it's slightly easier to see which blobs are growing and which are getting shoved. But I agree that it isn't easy, and I think it's because the CPAN Map wasn't meant to be time-lapsed like this.
Edit: if you go to the mapofcpan.org site and click on pixels, I think you'll figure out what the blue areas are.
Re:Map of CPAN - The Movie
by grantmnz on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:19PM
(#4685305)
If you go to mapofcpan.org and click on "Need more help?" it explains more about what the map is showing you.
Only namespaces that contain 30 or more distributions get a colour and a label - to keep the map from getting too cluttered. The remaining modules are submerged under the light blue "primordial soup".
Since the individual distributions are arranged alphabetically and laid out along a Hilbert curve, adding an extra distribution to 'Acme' pushes every other namespace along.
And yeah - the Hilbert curve probably isn't ideally suited to being animated :-)
- Why is there blue space between segments?
- Why do the colored (non-blue) segments crawl around instead of growing/shrinking?
- If any segment actually changes size, I can't tell because of the crawl
- If the crawling is due to "continental drift," there's not an obvious path that the flow takes. I can see that it starts in the upper left corner, but when I notice that the path squiggles around, I have to study it for far too long to figure out where the bits are headed.
Edit: if you go to the mapofcpan.org site and click on pixels, I think you'll figure out what the blue areas are.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-filling_curve
Only namespaces that contain 30 or more distributions get a colour and a label - to keep the map from getting too cluttered. The remaining modules are submerged under the light blue "primordial soup".
Since the individual distributions are arranged alphabetically and laid out along a Hilbert curve, adding an extra distribution to 'Acme' pushes every other namespace along.
And yeah - the Hilbert curve probably isn't ideally suited to being animated :-)
For reference here's the HN discussion about mapofcpan.org from last year: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3355859