News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by beagle3 on Sunday October 21, 2012 @10:06PM (#4681532)
You are absolutely correct about everything. Two additional points:

1. While the brainwashing is there, and is very effective, the major carriers (AT&T, Verizon) will make you pay the same monthly charge whether you bought a "subsidized" phone from them or not. So instead of subsidized phone vs. unsubsidized phone (the way you have it in most of the world), what you have in the US is sucker-with-a-lower-price-tag ($200), vs. sucker-with-a-higher-price-tag (e.g. $650 if bought from Apple) - your service cost will be the same (with the exception that if you brought your own phone, you won't pay an ETF if you leave early).

2. Yes, it is exclusively in the US that you pay for incoming - and that's for historical reasons. Unlike essentially everywhere else, there is no special area code for mobile, so you can't tell if you're calling a mobile phone, so -- back in the days when calls to mobile cost more everywhere -- there was no other way to handle this. But the US public has gotten used to it, so no company is thinking of changing that - people here think its normal to pay for a received text message (SMS) as well...

Mobile phone service in the US is a ripoff, but it will not change because the public is not aware that is the case, and congress is bought and paid for.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by lotsofpulp on Sunday October 21, 2012 @10:49PM (#4681641)
Regarding #1, if you don't buy subsidized, you are also able to get a phone that works all over the world (i.e. unlocked), and one that the carrier can't exercise over the software so you can tether/root/get software updates. The latter is at least that's true with Android (Galaxy Nexus specifically).

Another plus is that in the US the wireless coverage providers MANDATE buying data if you use a smartphone on their network, subsidized or not (which is BS, but the FCC is bought and paid for). If you don't want your wireless provider to know you have a smartphone, you have to buy it unsubsidized.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by beagle3 on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:08AM (#4681813)
> you are also able to get a phone that works all over the world (i.e. unlocked)

FYI: Any Verizon subsidized phones are unlocked-for-carriers-outside-the-US, if you just ask, 60 days after you bought them. As far as I know, AT&T is not as nice. I did this with my VZW 4S, which works beautifully in Europe when I travel there. So if you're a verizon customer and you don't get the "subsidized" phone, you are being an even bigger sucker than the average US mobile phone user.

Rumors are that the iPhone5 on verizon is always unlocked - don't know if that's true.

Oh, and specifically for the iphone, AT&T will unlock it for you after the contract is over, or you paid the ETF. But as far as I know, they won't do it for any other phone.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by lotsofpulp on Monday October 22, 2012 @01:15AM (#4681942)
I also heard that Verizon's iPhone 5 is GSM unlocked, but I was unaware that any phone other than the iPhone had SIM trays. And yes, ATT does unlock your iPhone now after contract (just began allowing it this summer, it's ridiculous how long that took).

As anyone reading will probably notice, I've been quite jaded with my interactions with the mobile carriers. Actually, until this year, I would renew my contract, then sell the locked iPhone on eBay and make a few hundred dollars. I haven't done it this year, but I think the widespread availability of unlocked iPhones noawadays probably lessens the value of a locked iPhone quite a bit.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by rogerbinns on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:42AM (#4681881)
Further to point 2, it always costs more to call a cell phone. In the US the recipient essentially pays the extra over a landline and gets a bulk discount for doing so. In most other countries the caller pays more for making the call to a cell phone. The price difference can be staggering.

Look at this (random) calling card rates page where it gives the price per minute to call from the US to various countries: http://callingcards.com/shopping/qj-phone-card-usa.asp

Note how much more it usually costs to call cell phones versus land lines, sometimes ten times as much. Don't forget the rate includes the transit of the call from the US to the country as well so the actual difference can be even greater.

It does seem somewhat fairer that the person making the call is hit with the extra charges, but at the same time it is far harder for them to get a bulk discount since the charges come from the recipient's network.

All that said the SMS situation is because the US carriers could get away with it.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by EwanToo on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:23AM (#4682260)
As an aside, it doesn't cost more to call a cell phone for any reason other than "Because people will pay more".

If anything, mobile networks are less troublesome to maintain than fixed line networks, the equipment needs a lot less human interaction, and generally cost much less to run.

If you were building a voice only telephone network today, it would not involve wires into people's houses.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by beagle3 on Monday October 22, 2012 @09:34AM (#4683037)
> If you were building a voice only telephone network today, it would not involve wires into people's houses.

That's something that is easy to agree about, however,

> As an aside, it doesn't cost more to call a cell phone for any reason other than "Because people will pay more".

That's something that is hard to argue unless you have an insider's breakdown of the costs, and assumptions about the cost of capital. (specifically, with all the wires already in place, it is NOW, for the landline company cheaper to use that infrastructure - the costs have already paid by an entity which has gone bankrupt or otherwise wrote it down)

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by EwanToo on Monday October 22, 2012 @11:29AM (#4683552)
Well clear numbers are pretty hard to get yes, but BT Openreach is a good source of data, as a government forced wholesaler of land line services.

Ofcom has set the current price of wholesale line rental (i.e. a land line only service, no broadband), at £98.81 for 2012-2013. [1]

This price gives Openreach a small operating profit, but not much at all. Remember that Openreach employs 19,000 field engineers to maintain the UK phone network, it's a massively expensive task. [2]

A mobile network has much less fixed infrastructure, and with it comes much lower costs, even disregarding the actual cost of laying wires (as you say, that's largely been paid for now, even the BT FTTC roll out is "only" costing £2.5 billion, or about £100 per home in the UK)

1 - http://media.ofcom.org.uk/2012/02/06/ofcom-proposes-new-whol...

2 - http://www.btplc.com/mobile/Careercentre/Meetourpeople/Peopl...

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by beagle3 on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:35PM (#4685385)
Not sure why this was downvoted (I upvoted, for giving hard data, even if I think the reasoning is flawed).

I don't think these numbers are at all helpful - without taking into account e.g. how much openreach paid for the infrastructure it is using (did it inherit? did it create all?). Also, the efficiency of openreach is an unknown that makes every other number moot. They employ 19,000 employees, but that does not mean that a similar level of service cannot be reached with 5,000.

I suspect that your basic claim as I understand it: That if we started TODAY, wireless would be cheaper. But I can't tell if it's true when you ignore all sunk costs everywhere - which, practically, you do.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by EwanToo on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @11:42AM (#4688596)
Openreach inherited the original infrastructure yes, it was built when it was owned by the UK government, then passed to BT, then Openreach (a BT subsidiary).

Openreach have since been responsible for the upkeep, and are rolling out fibre to the cabinet using largely BT's own money, rather than government funded.

As to their efficiency, well I'm not sure who else has as similar setup of firewalls between their retail business (BT selling to normal people and businesses), wholesale business (sells to ISPs and telcos), and network infrastructure (sells to BT wholesale and larger telcos), so it is a hard one to judge, but if they could do it with 5,000 people, I'm not sure why they wouldn't.

Over the years BT have got rid of an awful lot of staff, they're definitely more efficient now than they have been previously.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by EwanToo on Monday October 22, 2012 @03:37PM (#4685060)
Not sure why this comment in particular got downvoted, bizarre..
Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by dima55 on Sunday October 21, 2012 @10:11PM (#4681547)
That's not 100% true. At least Tmobile doesn't make you pay the full monthly cost if you didn't get a subsidized phone from them. So if you're using Verizon or AT&T you're indeed a sucker, but there're options..
Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by eli on Sunday October 21, 2012 @11:06PM (#4681682)
T-Mobile is the only major US carrier to do this. I use them and I think they're a great bargain, but it's not a good option for everyone. Their coverage map is much smaller than AT&T or Verizon and they are not a good choice of carrier if you want an iPhone.
Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by jacalata on Monday October 22, 2012 @01:01AM (#4681917)
I'm pretty sure that the 'no special code for mobile' and 'recipient pays' concepts were part of the same plan - companies worried that nobody would call a mobile if they knew it was different or more expensive, so they made it look exactly the same to call one, and make the assumed 'high powered exec' cover the cost difference in order to receive calls. I'm not sure why this only happened in the US - was it the first country to have consumer mobile phones?
Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by beagle3 on Monday October 22, 2012 @09:29AM (#4683018)
I have no first hand knowledge, but I'd assume there's no malice involved. In the US, every state has a different area code, and calling within your area code (and possibly a few others) is "local", and other area codes are "long distance".

At the time, the infrastructure wasn't there for a US national mobile area code - the installations were state local, and as a result, mobile numbers were state local. And it all follows from there.

The US phone infrastructure (both landline and mobile) was there first, and as a result, suffered from a lot of legacy that the European system was able to avoid by virtue of having more time to think about it, observe how it was done wrong, and do it right.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by andybak on Monday October 22, 2012 @05:20AM (#4682364)
I could never work out why people in the US were so resistant to buying their phones from a 3rd party.

Are you saying that carriers don't offer any 'SIM-only' packages? i.e. You can't ask for a contract without a free phone?

If so - is there a workaround? If I went for a package with the cheapest possible dumb-phone, how much would I save?

For comparison I'm on a $28/month package with Virgin that I can cancel at any time (1 months notice) and has unlimited data and SMS. No phone included. This is a particularly good deal but even before this there were similar deals but with a data cap.

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by beagle3 on Monday October 22, 2012 @11:10AM (#4683457)
> Are you saying that carriers don't offer any 'SIM-only' packages? i.e. You can't ask for a contract without a free phone?

You can; but at AT&T and Verizon, it's not cheaper than if you do get a phone, so everyone gets a phone. And for quite a few people, T-Mobile and Sprint are unacceptable (coverage, technology).

Re:Nokia’s price for exclusivity by freehunter on Monday October 22, 2012 @09:19AM (#4682977)
You can get prepaid, and there are second-hand networks that will sell you a SIM-only plan (reselling from leased space on a major carrier). Virgin sells prepaid here in the US as well. Most smartphones require a data plan on the carriers here though, which costs a lot more. Most prepaid plans come with a phone included ($100 for the phone and x number of minutes, then you add more minutes by paying more).