Had Cortez and his men died in the jungle, that would not have been regarded as a bold act of leadership.
From what I understand, Nokia did this because of the "warring factions" and duplicated effort across the company. Killing it early was likely seen as a strategy for reducing cultural problems later.
Except every kid I knew when I grew up swapped their Commodore 64 (which they had) for an Amiga 500. The Amiga was widely successful and ahead of everything else at the time, at least within the consumer price-point.
What killed Commodore was that they got complacent, lazy and slept on their laurels.
When the PC finally overtook the Amiga (much like Nokia, RIM being overtaken now, etc) it took too much time until they realized what was happening, and when they did, it was too late. They had no products to offer which could match the competition, and slowly, but surely they went into bankruptcy.
Commodore-64 to Commodore Amiga (unsuccessful)
Actually the Amiga was a lot more successful than you'd think looking at the American market (it was mostly successful in Europe: http://www.amigau.com/aig/sales.html - there is no reliable public data about exact numbers but its somewhere around 4+ million units, most of which in Europe).With the success of the Amiga 500 commodore had a decent chance at staying alive and even prospering, if not for extreme mismanagement & very questionable business decisions (that started before the time of the Amiga).
semi-successful at best. The Mac didn't get the same marketshare in the 80'ies as the Apple II had.
edit: after reading the article I see that this is the actual point he's making, though he claims that they could have made an extra 3 Billion from selling the symbian phones if they'd focussed on that, and only got 1 Billion from Microsoft. Except he pads the numbers by assuming they'd have hit their 150 Million sales targets and sold another 50 million devices at an average of $200 (unsubsidized) and got 33% or $66 dollars profit from each one (neatly equalling the subsidy of $68 they get from Microsoft from each WinPhone they sell at current sales rates).
Of course, the Microsoft payments continue and were guaranteed, whereas Symbian was a gamble and is, frankly, now dead so the "price" of this choice becomes less with every passing day and depending on which numbers you pick out of the air, they could already be ahead on the deal.
But I agree that this seemed pretty reckless especially since WP7 was/is still at such an early phase. It basically multiplied the risk that future nokia phones would be crap by the risk that windows would be crap.
While switching from Symbian to WP7 may have been a good idea, to publicly announce that you're dumping the platform of your best selling phones seems like a pretty big blunder.
Yahoo's approach seems better to me. I'm sure that Marissa has a game plan for products that they'll EOL and directions that'll change but they're keeping it close the vest to not shake things up publicly too much.