I remember reading that pine trees give off a chemical that is a natural human bronchodilator.
One thought of why people love hiking, especially in piney woods, is that the chemical allows humans to process more oxygen which in turn helps them feel more "energized".
I point this out for two reasons:
1. It's a fascinating bit of trivie
2. It highlights that there are MANY confounding variables so it will always be tough to figure out the isolated impact.
Keeping the mind busy with beautiful things and being physically exhausted can heal a lot of things.
Its like surfing on a big day - you are just too tired to be depressive afterwards. It feels like a weight blanket.
I don't have the energy to do all that when I'm down though. I hate all sports though I do like hiking (there's no team or competitive bullshit) but I'm too clumsy for it.
Oddly a lot of the “guys with road bikes wearing full gear” seem to just ride on the road anyway. I have no idea why, I’ve double checked the laws and I’m allowed to ride there.
A few months ago I tried walking with a weighted vest, and my body and brain got completely shocked in a really good way. Wakes up everything. So that is in my mix now.
Walking with 20 then 40 lbs was a lot easier than I expected, and the results were much greater.
I can definitely tell that the Adderall I was prescribed had an immediate, huge benefit. Not sure about the vitamin D.
But I really appreciated that he took a wide angle look at my health.
Hiking has the biggest effect though.
I think maybe the problem is that therapists are diagnosing people, and psychiatrists are prescribing pills based on those diagnoses, but neither are ordering bloodwork to check for deficiencies. Which leads to a lot of people suffering from lack of basic health, and treating the symptoms with SSRIs that have withdrawl symptoms a million times worse than most of the problems they treat.
Now to your point, I seriously doubt that vitamin D will hold up against anti-depressants and therapy if we control for other health and quality of life issues. I just think there is a ton of misdiagnosis, and lack of root cause analysis in the mental health field, and health care in general.