Re:Apple to Soon Take Up to 30% Cut from All Patreon Creator...
by spacebanana7 on Thursday January 29, 2026 @05:43AM
(#46808336)
> If Apple can legally claim 30% of your salary then a doctor using an iPad to demonstrate results of a scan to a patient has to pay Apple 30% of their consultation fee.
Apple could absolutely do this. They could say that professional medical use of macOS requires a commercial license, and the price of that commercial licence could be linked to revenue.
Doctors - or rather their hospital IT/procurement departments - would be held to the terms of service they agree to. Far more rigorously than ordinary consumers.
Re:Apple to Soon Take Up to 30% Cut from All Patreon Creator...
by willtemperley on Thursday January 29, 2026 @06:12AM
(#46808603)
If that were legally enforcable, which is almost certainly not the case, Microsoft and Google could do the same, making your argument moot in this context.
Re:Apple to Soon Take Up to 30% Cut from All Patreon Creator...
by spacebanana7 on Thursday January 29, 2026 @06:41AM
(#46808890)
Every software company can do this. Oracle Java is free for personal use but if you use it in prod you have to pay a licence based on the number of employees in your company. Epic games takes 5% of your revenue above a million if you use unreal for a game. Docker desktop requires a paid license if you have over 250 employees or $10 million in revenue.
Re:Apple to Soon Take Up to 30% Cut from All Patreon Creator...
by willtemperley on Thursday January 29, 2026 @07:33AM
(#46809324)
Let's continue with the reductio ad absurdum - a taxi driver uses their iPhone to navigate. Can Apple take 30% of their revenue?
Re:Apple to Soon Take Up to 30% Cut from All Patreon Creator...
by spacebanana7 on Thursday January 29, 2026 @09:50AM
(#46810927)
Absolutely, if the taxi driver signs a contract / agrees to terms of service. What law prohibits them from charging that? This is why open source is so important.
Re:Apple to Soon Take Up to 30% Cut from All Patreon Creator...
by bigDinosaur on Thursday January 29, 2026 @07:10AM
(#46809122)
What would make this legally unenforceable?
It's not, it's just factually wrong.
If Apple can legally claim 30% of your salary then a doctor using an iPad to demonstrate results of a scan to a patient has to pay Apple 30% of their consultation fee.
That's reductio ad absurdum.
Lol.