So for example if a mgr had bad peer and subordinate reviews but a positive manager review HR would step in and force a resolution. If none of (or only a minority of) your peers or subordinates trust you it didn't matter what your manager thought. Now that said training was always the first thing to try, which in fairness we did with any knowledge worker.
As for contributions and measuring impact yes, the entire team had bonuses based on performance and results. In fact we tracked milestones to expected costs and if a team beat it they were rewarded. Not just a team lead but the whole team. I so hated filling out WBS cards.
While I was there we had three changes in various leadership positions because of team dynamics. Honestly, at least in my group my complaint was sometimes to high a sensitivity to team grumbling.
But I know there were places in the organization where protecting management was done, which is complete BS in my book.
I also totally disagreed with some arbitrary numbers we had to meet, like having a certain percentage of our project developed offshore. That was asinine and made no logical sense but to supposedly save a few dollars, and my bet it cost us more than it ever saved us.
A good employer will recognize this and look for a root cause after one or especially more A player(s) leave, a bad employer will just look at how to blame the employee(s) that left for the problem(s).
And at least in my team these people repeatedly failed. I never saw someone moved out that hadn't been warned, talked to and had some training.
So I get why people are skeptical but I really believe more teams worked like mine than the others. I was exposed to a lot of divisions in a short period and we knew there were horrible teams. unfortunately the bad teams always seem to get more attention and play.
But without having all the facts I can't say which really was the most common, except to say I think it worked well for our team overall. Not to say there wasn't plenty of BS pandering and crap we did otherwise. Hence why I left and sought out different environments.