Re:Ask HN: Why what worked for GE didnt work for Microsoft
by pootch on Saturday October 20, 2012 @11:23AM
(#4677264)
Anytime a company goes from being a company into essentially being a bank you can smell the failure. GM did it too and we all ended up paying off that bad debt. Turning into a bank is not a success in business, its showing the world that you have no other options but to profit from carried interest.
b) GE under Welch was an old, established, stagnant company. My personal theory (pure speculation) is that GE had built up a lot of inefficient processes: whenever something bad happens, regardless of the probability of it recurring, the natural response of (especially large) corporations is to write another procedure to prevent it from recurring. GE also likely accreated lots of ineffective employees over the years (to write and follow the ineffective processes ;-).
As a result, GE under Welch was able to cut a lot of costs out of their manufacturing processes by re-evaluating the cost vs. effectiveness vs. benefits of them. All those cut costs would flow to their bottom line, at least for a while.
Note that GE's stock has been pretty flat (struggling, even) for the last several years. According to my speculation above, this would be because they squeezed all the excess costs out of their manufacturing and their financial division took it on the chin with the downturn, leaving them sucking wind. So...
c) Jack Welch's changes happened in a different era and were in response to a different situation. A solution that works for a totally different company than Microsoft in a totally different era isn't likely to be effective when applied blindly to e.g. Microsoft.