And that doesn't require using newer functionality.
And this has nothing to do with 1996, or 2004 glibc at all. In fact, glibc makes this otherwise impossible task actually possible: you can force to link with older symbols, but that solves only a fraction of the problem of what you're trying to achieve. Statically linking / musl does not solve this either. At some point musl is going to use a newer syscall, or any other newer feature, and you're broke again.
Also, what is so hard about building your software in your "security updates only" server? Or a chroot of it at least ? As I was saying below, I have a Debian 2006-ish chroot for this purpose....
The problem is with the Linux dynamic linking, and the idea that you must not statically link the glibc code. And you can circumvent it by freezing your glibc abstraction interface, so that if you need to add another function, you do so by making another library entirely. But I don't know if musl does that.
If you want to go to such level, ELF is also forward compatible in that sense.
This is completely irrelevant, because what the developer is going to see is the binaries he builts in XP SP3 no longer work in XP SP2 because of a link error: the _statically linked_ runtime is going to call symbols that are not in XP SP2 DLLs (e.g. the DecodePointer debacle).
> If you use the Linux kernel directly, it is forward compatible in that sense.
Or not, because there will be a note in the ELF headers with the minimum kernel version required, which is going to be set to a recent version even if you do not use any newer feature. (unless you play with the toolchain) (PE has similar field too, leading to the "not a valid win32 executable" messages).
> And, of course, there is no issue at all with statically linked code.
I would say statically linked code is precisely the root of all these problems.
In addition to bring more problems of its own. E.g. games that dynamically link with SDL can be patched to have any other SDL version, including one with bugfixes for X support, audio, etc. Games that statically link with SDL? Sorry..
> And you can circumvent it by freezing your glibc abstraction interface, so that if you need to add another function, you do so by making another library entirely. But I don't know if musl does that.
Funnily, I think that is exactly the same as the solution I'm proposing for this conundrum: just (dynamically) link with the older glibc ! Voila: your binary now works with glibc from 1996 and glibc from 2026.
Frankly, glibc is already the project with the best binary compatibility of the entire Linux desktop , if not the only one with a binary compatibility story at all . The kernel is _not_ better in this regard (e.g. /dev/dsp).
I know, I've done that.
> just (dynamically) link with the older glibc!
Except that the older glibc is unmaintained and very hard to get a hold of and use. If you solve that, yeah, it's the same.
No, you can't. When you use 7-era toolchain (e.g. VS 2012) it sets the minimum client version in PE header to Vista, not XP much less 2k.
If you use VC++6 in 7, then yes, you can; but that's not really that different from me using a Debian Etch chroot to build.
Even within XP era this happens, since there are VS versions that target XP _SP2_ and produce binaries that are not compatible with XP _SP1_. That's the "DecodePointer" debacle I was mentioning. _Even_ if you do not use any "SP2" feature (as few as they are), the runtime (the statically linked part; not MSVCRT) is going to call DecodePointer, so even the smallest hello world will catastrophically fail in older win32 version.
Just Google around for hundreds of confused developers.
> Except that the older glibc is unmaintained and very hard to get a hold of and use.
"unmaintained" is another way of saying "frozen" or "security updates only" I guess. But ... hard to get a hold of ? You are literally running it on your the "security updates only" server that you wanted to target in the first place!
Yes, you can! There are even multiple Windows 10 era toolchains that officially support XP. VS 2017 was the last release that could build XP binaries.
In my experience, that's not quite accurate. I'm working on a GUI program that targets Windows NT 4.0, built using a Win11 toolchain. With a few tweaks here and there, it works flawlessly. Microsoft goes to great lengths to keep system DLLs and the CRT forward- and backward-compatible. It's even possible to get libc++ working: https://building.enlyze.com/posts/targeting-25-years-of-wind...
You don't want to believe how many old binaries broke. Lot of ABI upgrades like libpng, ncurses, heck even stuff like readline and libtiff all changed just enough for linker errors to occur.
Ironically all the statically compiled stuff was fine. Some small things like you mention only linking to glibc and X11 was fine too. Funnily enough grabbing some old .so files from the RHEL 7 install and dumping them into LD_LIBRARY_PATH also worked better than expected.
But yeah, now that I'm writing this out, glibc was never the problem in terms of forwards compatibility. Now running stuff compiled on modern Ubuntu or RHEL 10 on the older OS, now that's a whole different story...
Why "better than expected"? I can run the entire userspace from Debian Etch on a kernel built two days ago... some kernel settings need to be changed (because of the old glibc! but it's not glibc's fault: it's the kernel who broke things), but it works.
> Now running stuff compiled on modern Ubuntu or RHEL 10 on the older OS, now that's a whole different story...
But this is a different problem, and no one makes promises here (not the kernel, not musl). So all the talk of statically linking with musl to get such type of compatibility is bullshit (at some point, you're going to hit a syscall/instruction/whatever that the newer musl does that the older kernel/hardware does not support).
I remember this in a heated LKML exchange, 13 years ago, look how the table has turned:
>
> Are you saying that pulseaudio is entering on some weird loop if the
> returned value is not -EINVAL? That seems a bug at pulseaudio.
Mauro, SHUT THE FUCK UP!
It's a bug alright - in the kernel. How long have you been a maintainer? And you still haven't learnt the first rule of kernel maintenance?
If a change results in user programs breaking, it's a bug in the kernel. We never EVER blame the user programs. How hard can this be to understand?
To make matters worse, commit f0ed2ce840b3 is clearly total and utter CRAP even if it didn't break applications. ENOENT is not a valid error return from an ioctl. Never has been, never will be. ENOENT means "No such file and directory", and is for path operations. ioctl's are done on files that have already been opened, there's no way in hell that ENOENT would ever be valid.
> So, on a first glance, this doesn't sound like a regression,
> but, instead, it looks tha pulseaudio/tumbleweed has some serious
> bugs and/or regressions.
Shut up, Mauro. And I don't _ever_ want to hear that kind of obvious garbage and idiocy from a kernel maintainer again. Seriously.
I'd wait for Rafael's patch to go through you, but I have another error report in my mailbox of all KDE media applications being broken by v3.8-rc1, and I bet it's the same kernel bug. And you've shown yourself to not be competent in this issue, so I'll apply it directly and immediately myself.
WE DO NOT BREAK USERSPACE!
Seriously. How hard is this rule to understand? We particularly don't break user space with TOTAL CRAP. I'm angry, because your whole email was so _horribly_ wrong, and the patch that broke things was so obviously crap. The whole patch is incredibly broken shit. It adds an insane error code (ENOENT), and then because it's so insane, it adds a few places to fix it up ("ret == -ENOENT ? -EINVAL : ret").
The fact that you then try to make excuses for breaking user space, and blaming some external program that used to work, is just shameful. It's not how we work.
Fix your f*cking "compliance tool", because it is obviously broken. And fix your approach to kernel programming.
LinusIf you are talking about _any_ other library, yes, that is a problem. My point is that glibc is the only one who even has a compatibility story.
How would that work given that glibc has gone through a soname change since then? If it's from 1996 are you sure the secret isn't that it uses non-g libc?
That suggests someone went to significantly more effort than "just dynamically link it".
Why is my entire argument so hard to understand? To build for a different glibc you do not have to do _any_ type of arcane magic or whatever you claim. You just build in a different system... or chroot... I have been doing that _myself_ for at least 15 years, and I know of other Linux desktop commercial shops that have been doing it for much, much longer. Chroots are _trivial_.
The trick? It's not statically linked, but dynamically linked. And it doesn't like with anything other than glibc, X11 ... and bdb.
At this point I think people just do not know how binary compatibility works at all. Or they refer to a different problem that I am not familiar with.