News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mathematics: Came across the following gag. Is it true? by sp332 on Saturday October 20, 2012 @08:40AM (#4676931)
You're constraining yourself to a wrong definition of what a number is. The number 0xA is not a different number from 0b1010 even though they have a different number of digits.

> Pi is not an infinite sequence

Pi is an infinite sequence.

I was talking about an infinite number of digits, but even this new definition is wrong. Pi is one single value. There are many ways to compute this value. Some of them include infinite series. Note the wording: "The calculation of π was revolutionized by the development of infinite series techniques". Other techniques were used before, and they are still valid. The only advantage of infinite series is that they are easier to calculate, and the approximations converge faster when you compute them on real (finite) hardware.

Re:Mathematics: Came across the following gag. Is it true? by lutusp on Saturday October 20, 2012 @08:18PM (#4678524)
> You're constraining yourself to a wrong definition of what a number is.

That's your problem, not mine. You keep trying to say that Pi is defined by our approximations of its value.

> Pi is one single value.

So, tell me, which part of "Pi is an infinite sequence" are you actually disagreeing with?

> There are many ways to compute this value.

You persist in confusing Pi with our efforts to approximate its value.

> Other techniques were used before, and they are still valid.

False. 22/7 is not valid. 355/113 is not valid. This is valid:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/423ieio63bsuaat/pi_w.png

The reason? Pi is a mathematical idea that happens to have a numerical value, but the idea transcends the value. The value is a coincidence, which is why choosing to express it as 1 to the base Pi changes nothing, and why arguing about the size of its approximations changes nothing.

> The only advantage of infinite series is that they are easier to calculate ...

No, they are much more difficult to calculate, but they convey more meaning. Infinite series are why Pi isn't just a number, any more than e is.

Re:Mathematics: Came across the following gag. Is it true? by sp332 on Saturday October 20, 2012 @09:18PM (#4678611)
> False. 22/7 is not valid. 355/113 is not valid.

Right, those are approximations. Those are not what we are talking about.

> This is valid: https://www.dropbox.com/s/423ieio63bsuaat/pi_w.png

I agree that it is valid. It is one of many ways of calculating the value of pi. Here is another one: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/2/2a/Pi-... Also there are iterative algorithms. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi#Computer_era_and_iterative_a...

> No, they are much more difficult to calculate, but they convey more meaning.

Again, I didn't mean approximations like 22/7. I was comparing them to e.g. the geometric method which took hundreds of years to extend to a few hundred digits. The geometric method conveys the same "meaning" because it is an exact description of pi, just like the infinite series and the iterative algorithms.

> Pi isn't just a number, any more than e is.

They are both just numbers. e is not infinite, in fact it is less than 3.

Re:Mathematics: Came across the following gag. Is it true? by lutusp on Sunday October 21, 2012 @01:07AM (#4679040)
> They are both just numbers.

No, they are ideas. The base of natural logarithms isn't an arbitrary number, it has special properties. It's the same with Pi -- they're ideas that happen to be expressible as numbers. But their numerical value is less important than their identity as ideas.

> e is not infinite, in fact it is less than 3.

Straw man. No one claimed otherwise. But e appears to have an infinite digital sequence, i.e. is "normal" in the mathematical sense.

But, as with Pi, the fact that e is likely "normal" is much less important than the idea it represents.

Re:Mathematics: Came across the following gag. Is it true? by sp332 on Sunday October 21, 2012 @10:03AM (#4679720)
OK. It sounded like you were saying that Pi is special just because there is an infinite series that describes it. It's trivial to make an infinite series that sums to any number. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_%28mathematics%29#Conver... So the number 2 is just as "infinite" as pi.
Re:Mathematics: Came across the following gag. Is it true? by lutusp on Sunday October 21, 2012 @04:05PM (#4680616)
> It sounded like you were saying that Pi is special just because there is an infinite series that describes it.

That would be because Pi is special because there are infinite series, and integrals, and mathematical identities, and limit expressions, that describe it in ways that give it a special meaning.

> So the number 2 is just as "infinite" as pi.

You're confusing the existence of a summation with its outcome. Obviously the sum of 2^-n for n between 0 and infinity (inclusive) is equal to 2, but that doesn't make 2 an infinite digital sequence, or in any other sense "infinite".