News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports by andrewljohnson on Saturday October 20, 2012 @04:49AM (#4676666)
I agree with your parent comment based on other information (details below), but I think his argument is wrong, or at least unsubstantiated. I was curious where his information was coming from, so I searched for some of his vocabulary. I googled for these things:

* backscatter cancer +"geometry of the delivery"

* backscatter cancer +"geometry of delivery"

* backscatter cancer +geometry

I didn't find that's how anyone talked about the risks, and so on that basis alone, I found your argument more compelling. However, I did find information that furthers the anti-backscatter argument in the same way you argue the pro, that is quantitative studies:

"research studies have concluded that a small number of cancer cases would result from scanning hundreds of millions of passengers a year."

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=europe-bans....

I looked further to try and find studies that the SA article vaguely mentioned, and I found this one by Columbia University: http://www.columbia.edu/~djb3/papers/radiol7.pdf

This paper doesn't talk about the geometry of exposure, but it does say that while the machines are basically safe, it also uses statistics to show that:

* "there will be some cancers induced by the associated radiation exposure" (billions of scans means definitely some cancer)

* "risks will be somewhat higher for children, for radiosensitive individuals, and, particularly, for aircrew and frequent fliers."

* these machines may cause cancers cause by malfunctions

So, if you believe the machines will kill a few hundred people or the terrorists will kill a few hundred people, shouldn't we just save our money, and our liberty? I don't think it's just an inconvenience - I think it's a bunch of needless cancers.

There are no comments on this comment yet.