Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by moskie on Friday October 19, 2012 @01:54PM
(#4674645)
How about giving credit where credit is due? This shows that the situation is better today than it was yesterday.
Yes, I know the ideal would be that all of our issues get resolved immediately. But how about we recognize that this could be a step towards that end?
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by daeken on Friday October 19, 2012 @01:56PM
(#4674658)
How is the situation actually better? If you believe that these scanners are harmful, then it's pretty hard to argue that shuffling them around has actually done any good; it's just doing harm in a different place.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by bunderbunder on Friday October 19, 2012 @02:02PM
(#4674704)
Well, if they're moving them from busy airports to less-busy ones then hypothetically less harm is being done overall, on account of fewer people being exposed.
Less bad is still no good. . . but it's still less bad, too.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by mcantelon on Saturday October 20, 2012 @03:14AM
(#4676561)
Rural folks may be statistically less likely to be aware of the issue or make a fuss.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by HelloMcFly on Friday October 19, 2012 @01:59PM
(#4674687)
If something is harmful, I consider the situation "better" every time significantly fewer people are exposed to the harm. I'd rather have three backscatter scanners operating at Yeager Airport in Charleston, WV than operating in Hartsfield-Jackson Airport in Atlanta.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by zheng on Friday October 19, 2012 @02:36PM
(#4674862)
Of course, if you live in Charleston, WV, then this doesn't really help you much personally.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by mosburger on Friday October 19, 2012 @06:24PM
(#4675633)
Yeah - as a resident of Portland, Maine who frequently flies out of my home airport to visit clients, I'm not so psyched about the small airports getting the old radiation machines.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by HelloMcFly on Friday October 19, 2012 @11:57PM
(#4676319)
Just opt-out. I always did. It's not a great situation, but slow progress beats no progress.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by Laremere on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:37PM
(#4675075)
It shows that they're aware of the negative public pressure. They may just be playing a shell game at the moment, but at least the pressure is forcing them to respond.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by sologoub on Friday October 19, 2012 @02:02PM
(#4674705)
Agreed, I'd rather not have them anywhere...
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by hartez on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:16PM
(#4675001)
And all that shuffling costs tax dollars.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by grandalf on Friday October 19, 2012 @02:16PM
(#4674783)
The spokesperson says that the machines are not being removed due to radiation safety concerns. Thus there is no credit to be given.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by markbao on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:46PM
(#4675117)
They might publicly state that radiation safety concerns are not the reason, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it's true. If they admit the reason is radiation safety concerns, then they wouldn't be able to relocate them to smaller airports because they would still cause safety concerns at smaller airports.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by technomancy on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:45PM
(#4675110)
I would call it attempting to save face. Don't trust what they say about their motivation.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by flatline on Friday October 19, 2012 @02:27PM
(#4674830)
I love how dissenting opinions get downvoted like this on HN. Moskie was not hostile or otherwise in violation of the site guidelines; this is exactly the type of comment that should not be downvoted.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by ojbyrne on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:11PM
(#4674986)
I'm curious what you think the exact purpose of clicking on an up or down arrow is supposed to express?
There is nothing in the guidelines or faq to actually say what the purpose is, and I could see an argument for "quality" being the criteria, but there's nothing wrong with using the arrow to express agreement or disagreement, from what I can see.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by breadbox on Friday October 19, 2012 @03:41PM
(#4675092)
It may not be "wrong" per se, but it could easily have the unhappy result of making dissent invisible (or at least less visible). Unpopular opinions, if expressed honestly and well, ought to be encouraged.
Re:TSA Removes X-Ray Body Scanners From Major Airports
by drivebyacct2 on Friday October 19, 2012 @02:14PM
(#4674774)
How is this possibly a step in the right direction? The direction that they need to move in is one they will NEVER move it. That'd be like you going to your boss and saying "I'm redundant, useless and ironically harmful. Please throw me out."
Because that's what needs to happen with the entire security theatre that encompasses DoHS and TSA.
In other words: "So, we have these machines that may be harmful and cause a PR disaster, so instead of doing the right thing (protecting people from harm, and all), let's move them to smaller airports, where it's much less likely to cause a stir."
This is so messed up!