News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Thursday January 22, 2026 @12:06PM (#46721968)
This will sound pedantic but I'll explain why it matters: the exact wording is "We need to do something useful with AI", because the current (editorialized) submission title (of an already slanted article) makes it sound like people don't know what to do with AI.

We already know many useful things to do; there are already 10,000 startups (9789 out of YC alone, 4423 of which are coding-related) doing various ostensibly useful things. And there a ton more use-cases discussed in the comments here and elsewhere. But because of the headline the discussion is missing the much more important point!

Satya's point is, we need to do things that improve people's lives. Specific quotes from TFA:

>... "do something useful that changes the outcomes of people and communities and countries and industries."

> "We will quickly lose even the social permission to take something like energy, which is a scarce resource, and use it to generate these tokens, if these tokens are not improving health outcomes, education outcomes, public sector efficiency, private sector competitiveness, across all sectors, small and large, right?" said Nadella. "And that, to me, is ultimately the goal."

Which is absolutely right. He's the only Big Tech CEO I've heard of who constantly harps on the human and economic benefit angle of LLMs, whereas so many others talk -- maybe in indirect ways -- about replacing people and/or only improving company outcomes (which are usually better for only a small group of people: the shareholders.)

He's still a CEO, so I have no illusions that he's any different from the rest of them (he's presided over a ton of layoffs, after all.) But he seems to be the only CEO whose interests appear to be aligned with the rest of ours.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by tempodox on Thursday January 22, 2026 @12:37PM (#46722498)
The number of startups is no proof they’re doing anything useful. It only proves that the founders think they can make money with it.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Thursday January 22, 2026 @01:52PM (#46723561)
And potentially their investors, for the startups that got funding. And maybe their customers, for the startups that are already hitting millions in ARR in a year or less. There are some of the numbers out there worth looking up.

Is your contention that we don't already know how to do useful things with AI?

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by orangea on Thursday January 22, 2026 @03:57PM (#46725044)
> We already know many useful things to do; there are already 10,000 startups (9789 out of YC alone, 4423 of which are coding-related) doing various ostensibly useful things.

I don't think you meant "ostensibly".

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Friday January 23, 2026 @12:34AM (#46728810)
You're right, maybe the better word would have been "presumably."
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by xracy on Thursday January 22, 2026 @06:08PM (#46726287)
> We already know many useful things to do; there are already 10,000 startups (9789 out of YC alone, 4423 of which are coding-related) doing various ostensibly useful things. And there a ton more use-cases discussed in the comments here and elsewhere. But because of the headline the discussion is missing the much more important point!

There has to be gold in the West! Look at all of the prospectors moving there to get rich on gold! You have not demonstrated that there are 10k uses of AI, you've only demonstrated that there are 10k "businesses" interested in making money off of AI. Just like there were 10k+ crypto-currencies... Just like there were 10k+ "uber but for..." apps. Where are these failed gold-rush attempts now?

Investors are currently rewarding the words "AI", so (to extend the analogy) when the gold moved, the gold rushers moved to where they thought the gold would be.

Also your emphasis doesn't change the reading of the sentence.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Friday January 23, 2026 @01:32AM (#46729184)
Cryptocurrency startups were just ways to bring "novel" trading strategies into the world of unregulated finance. The only "innovation" there was freedom from regulation and accountability, which turned out just as you'd expect. (Also there are still a surprising number of crypto companies plugging away out there.)

"Uber but for ..." apps were either just bad ideas, or ended up serving niche markets or reincarnating as features in Uber, DoorDash and the like. The only innovation there was new facets of the gig economy, which is still expanding BTW.

Now if you look at the AI gold rush, the differences are stark:

1. A lot of AI startups are already making a lot of money and growing at a record pace. Some of the numbers out there are bonkers.

2. The domains they are targeting are all over, including accounting, education, energy, games, healthcare, sales, pharma, drug discovery, agriculture, legal, customer support, semiconductor design, travel, retail... you name it.

3. The demand is so high, AI hyperscalers have TRIPLE-DIGIT BILLIONS EACH in backlog, i.e. commited revenue they could not realize because of severe capacity crunch.

4. Literally all the world's major governments, which typically take ages to catch up to technological change, are scrambling to get in on the AI wave.

All within only ~3 years.

I'd say there's some utility there.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by tabs_or_spaces on Friday January 23, 2026 @03:07AM (#46729829)
> A lot of AI startups are already making a lot of money and growing at a record pace. Some of the numbers out there are bonkers.

Do you have examples of this? I'm aware of raises, but not aware of any profitable ai companies yet

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Friday January 23, 2026 @03:59AM (#46730182)
I'm not sure about "profitable" because these are very young (2 - 3 years old) private companies, but there have been a few reports showing their growth indicating very strong PMF i.e. utility:

https://a16z.com/revenue-benchmarks-ai-apps/

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/03/15/y-combinator-startups-are-fa...

https://medium.com/@gjarrosson/ycs-revenue-explosion-497ea17...

https://stripe.com/blog/inside-the-growth-of-the-top-ai-comp...

https://www.ft.com/content/a9a192e3-bfbc-461e-a4f3-112e63d0b...

https://menlovc.com/perspective/2025-the-state-of-generative...

The revenue growth -- assuming these investors are not all colluding to fudge these numbers on a grand scale -- is way higher than what most have seen before.

Not everyone is hitting PMF of course, but apparently the success rate is also way higher than the past. Ignore the valuations and funding numbers, they are definitely inflated due to the hype.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by xracy on Sunday January 25, 2026 @04:38PM (#46758587)
> "I'm not sure about "profitable" because these are very young (2 - 3 years old) private companies"

In any other industry, this is the death knell for your company. It's only in tech where the investors drop so much money on early investments, that companies can get away with losing money for "2-3 years".

>The revenue growth -- assuming these investors are not all colluding to fudge these numbers on a grand scale -- is way higher than what most have seen before.

As a matter of strict numbers? The revenue growth could be higher just because of inflation.

You really seem to be doing a Gish Gallup here of links, which don't really prove any of your points. If there are specific metrics you can point to in these links that prove your point, then please call that out, but every one of these that I have clicked on has felt like a nothing burger.

> Menlovc link: is just talking about investment in AI, which proves my point

> FT: Paywall

> Stripe: You've got correlation, but not causation. An alternative thing you're proving could be that more investment in the space makes it easier to bring a product to market and earn revenue (How does this compare to SaaS Startups 5-10 years ago)

> Medium Link: is more of "proving my original point"

> CNBC: It's not clear what the metric is here that's making your case

> a16z: It looks to me like, this is actually proving the point that every one of these is considering "investments" as "revenue" which is wild.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Monday January 26, 2026 @06:32PM (#46773252)
> In any other industry...

Why bring up any other industry when we all know this is the VC playbook for tech companies, and has been working for them for decades? Reminder that Amazon, Uber, DoorDash etc were burning VC cash for upto a ~decade before becoming the giants they are now.

> As a matter of strict numbers? The revenue growth could be higher just because of inflation.

I have no idea how inflation, at < 3%, would matter in charts that show startups going from 0 to million+ in revenue in months to < a year.

> You really seem to be doing a Gish Gallup here of links, which don't really prove any of your points.

Yes, they do actually. I'm not sure why you think those links are talking about investments when they very clearly are about revenue. Open any of them up and cmd-F "revenue". Here's basically the gist of these links:

Investors: "Our startups are growing revenue at record pace" (10% growth week over week (!!) for YC startups as per the CNBC link)

MenloVC: "Enterprise decision makers tell us they're spending on AI at record pace" (E.g. "companies spent $37 billion on generative AI in 2025,3 up from $11.5 billion in 2024, a 3.2x year-over-year increase.")

Stripe: "Our AI startup customers are hitting revenue milestones at record pace."

It's not a "Gish Gallup" if it provides multiple, valid, different data-backed perspectives from different players in the ecosystem that all support the underlying thesis, which is that these AI startups are growing revenue at a unprecedented rates.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by xracy on Tuesday January 27, 2026 @10:38AM (#46781406)
> why bring up any other industry when this is the vc playbook

Because my point is how messed up the VC incentive structure for tech is. This is proved by comparing it to every other industry.

> Yes, they do actually. I'm not sure why you think those links are talking about investments when they very clearly are about revenue.

They are using the word "revenue", but can you be certain that the word means "revenue from product sales"? Or does it just mean "revenue from investment".

A couple of the articles specifically mentioned the series A rounds as part of "revenue generation". And my whole point was that investors celebrating how much faster they're investing in AI startups is a classic "begging the question" type fallacy. They are measuring themselves on how much money they are investing in startups, and then saying that is proof that the startups are valuable.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Wednesday January 28, 2026 @12:54AM (#46791573)
True, the tech VC incentive structure is weird from a typical perspective -- it is very hit-driven... throw money at a thousand startups burning cash to capture a market, and hope one of them becomes a unicorn. However, it has been working very well for them, so at this point nobody questions it.

> They are using the word "revenue", but can you be certain that the word means "revenue from product sales"? Or does it just mean "revenue from investment".

Investment and revenue are accounted for very differently, and if there's any mingling between them that would be highly problematic, probably fraudulent. For instance, there are tax implications, investments are not taxed but income from revenue can be. There can be all kinds of shenanigans that happen with finances in startups for sure, but those are typically unethical and illegal.

In this case they all are talking about revenue. Some articles do mention that funding rounds are also being affected because these companies have been hitting revenue milestones so much faster yet with much fewer people, but that is a separate aspect from the revenue.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by expedition32 on Friday January 23, 2026 @04:45PM (#46738362)
Nvidia is the hardware store selling shovels in this analogy...
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by xracy on Saturday January 24, 2026 @06:19PM (#46748756)
They're also trying to advertise and reinvest in the gold rush in an attempt to convince people there's gold here.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by radicalethics on Thursday January 22, 2026 @07:13PM (#46726794)
I'll explain it even better, trying to find something useful for the AI to do is the same is trying to find something useful for humans to do. Think that one through. You see, in a room that used to be just you and the boss now includes these whole other new entity called AI. Your boss is really interested in this new thing.

That is all.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Friday January 23, 2026 @01:49AM (#46729294)
Yes, but I think that is the exact attitude Satya's advising against: Where many leaders are looking inward to see how they can optimize their own businesses, they should be looking outward to see how they can improve the world.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by tstrimple on Friday January 23, 2026 @02:15AM (#46729473)
LOL! Does anyone think CEO's of major corporations are trying to improve the world? Honestly that's funny. Sorry if you really are this earnest. I wish you the best and hope you can maintain your outlook despite how disconnected from reality.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Friday January 23, 2026 @04:07AM (#46730244)
Eh, I did say he's not necessarily better than the rest of them, just more aligned with the rest of us, likely because he's more forward-looking than the others. He's seeing the backlash against AI, the pushback against data centers, and the social turmoil on the horizon, and he's saying, "Maybe we should not piss all the people off."

Also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46729271

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by techblueberry on Friday January 23, 2026 @09:42AM (#46733060)
“LOL! Does anyone think CEO's of major corporations are trying to improve the world?”

I think that there are some leaders who think about building a business in terms of providing value or an exchange of goods.

I think there’s a fundamental difference to society between a ceo that abstracts their role as building a product people value, and one that sees their role as hacking the stock price. The first still may do terrible things, but I think a lot of modern problems in society stem from the fact that deregulation changed the incentives from (1) to (2), but I’m pro any conversation that tries to move us back towards 1

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by cal_dent on Thursday January 22, 2026 @08:26PM (#46727270)
The problem for him and other leaders in the AI ecosystem is that they ran ahead of themselves to overpromise and that has muddied the water from a consumer perspective. That ultimately increases the risk that we throw the baby out with the bathwater as people get sour with it. I have no doubt LLM will be a feature of society going forward, but they have been reckless with the way they've gone about messaging it
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by techblueberry on Friday January 23, 2026 @09:37AM (#46732997)
It’s not just reckless it’s misanthropic. He’s rowing upstream against a messaging strategy of “fuck y’all!” Jobs? Fuck y’all!
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by journal on Thursday January 22, 2026 @10:19PM (#46727963)
i found good use for ai but no one cares about my world changing ambitions because they can't see unicorns anymore.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by rramadass on Friday January 23, 2026 @12:16AM (#46728710)
You are exactly right!

However, i would say Satya Nadella is quite different from other American CEOs (whose mantra is "greed is good") in that he comes from an Indian middle class family whose focus was on education/good-work and also being forced to take care of a son who suffered from cerebral palsy. All of these shaped his worldviews to be more empathetic of the "common man" which is reflected in his style of leadership.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by kasabali on Friday January 23, 2026 @04:11AM (#46730265)
You are either hopelessly naive or you're dishonest if you think he's even slightly less sociopathic than any other of 'em.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by rramadass on Friday January 23, 2026 @05:00AM (#46730578)
You are clueless if you think all CEOs are the same.
Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by keeda on Friday January 23, 2026 @01:45AM (#46729271)
Agreed on all counts; despite his stilted style of talking, he does come across as much more human than the rest.

That said, he's competing in circles dominated by absolute sociopaths. I can't imagine how you could battle with monsters in the abyss and not get Nietzsche'd at least a little bit.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by rramadass on Friday January 23, 2026 @05:07AM (#46730629)
He is balancing it pretty well without losing his fundamental values.

As this article itself alludes, in-spite of sinking a large amount of money into OpenAI he is genuinely looking for ways to make it useful rather than just make money.

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by FireBeyond on Friday January 23, 2026 @04:42PM (#46738338)
> also being forced to take care of a son who suffered from cerebral palsy

"forced"?

Re:Satya Nadella: "We need to find something useful for AI" by rererereferred on Friday January 23, 2026 @08:27AM (#46732228)
I feel his actual subtext underneath is "We need to do something useful with AI... because I invested in it". And he also goes on saying that calling it slop is bad for society. No, it's bad for the billionaires that invested in it.