News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by bluGill on Tuesday January 20, 2026 @06:26PM (#46699078)
Right vs left makes the assumption there are two sides / options. I have long thought that the 'left' was too extreem socialist - that doesn't mean I think current 'right' is any better.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Nevermark on Tuesday January 20, 2026 @09:36PM (#46700497)
The far right and left are always going to be homes for extremists, by definition.

And also practicality. Extreme people are highly motivated to push their agenda, and that requires a party. They adapt and find a way to participate, one way or another. Often simply by ramping up awareness of the opponent party's inevitable extremes.

The real question is: how do the moderates in a party operate, and are they currently tolerated and reasonably well represented within the party.

(I am using extreme here to mean a lack of operating in objective reality, or a strong will to divide who "matters" from who doesn't. Usually they go together.)

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @11:14AM (#46707696)
I think it's also matter what percentage of each party you would consider extreme, and I realize that's subjective
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by pjc50 on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @04:18AM (#46703080)
Would Kamala have invaded Greenland? No, of course not, and you know it.

Plenty of people wouldn't even count her as "left".

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by bluGill on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @07:44AM (#46704914)
you miss the point. The two sides are different they are not all viewpoints though.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @06:04AM (#46703897)
There are more options for your own opinions but those don't matter.

In a representative democracy it doesn't matter what you believe only what the person you vote for believes.

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by jonathanstrange on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @07:08AM (#46704526)
I know political discussions on HN are discouraged but let me chime in as the one who made a comment higher in the thread: From a European perspective, both US Republicans and US Democrats are right-wing, except for guys like Bernie Sanders whose positions are close to a typical European center-left social democrat.

However, IMHO this doesn't really matter because in the US both the left and the right tend to score high on authoritarianism on the freedom vs. authoritarian axis on a two-dimensional political spectrum view if you look at their actual policies and views they defend. That even includes the almost nonexistent US far left. Strongly anti-authoritarian viewpoints are extremely rare in the US. Even self-proclaimed "libertarians" in the US tend to have fairly authoritarian views when you press them about it, they're usually merely anti-federal-government pro business right-wing neoliberals.

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by viraptor on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @07:28AM (#46704729)
It's quite silly how people talk about the "left" in the US. There's barely any left present in politics. Much less "far/extreme left" or anything close to that. Nobody is really fighting for UBI, nationalisation of large utility-like corps, redoing healthcare completely, wealth taxes, dismantling the two-party system. And these ate still fairly chill ideas that recently happened in other countries, far from "extreme".
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by bluGill on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @07:42AM (#46704889)
Your position is they are not extreem. Mine is that what we call left is already too extreem. However what the 'right' wants is different but mostly not in the direction I want to go.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by DangitBobby on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @08:51AM (#46705697)
A minority of people in the developed world would agree with your assessment that the American left is "extreme". It's mostly American "centrists" and conservatives that think so.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by bluGill on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @09:16AM (#46706015)
Again though, the original point is that left/right assumes there are extremes. All you have said is that in the rest of the world the "left" is more extreme.

If that extreme is good or not is a mostly a value judgement - there is no right or wrong answer. There are consequences to what answer you pick though.

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by DangitBobby on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @09:55AM (#46706543)
The thing about extremes is you can make anything so by choosing a reference point. My reference is from the centerpoint of most prosperous and educated countries, because those are most likely to be ones with good ideas to be emulated. All decision we make are based on value judgements. Obviously there's no way to know what the most sensible thing is but in absence of perfect heuristics, "what other successful countries think" seems like a good one.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by layla5alive on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @04:17PM (#46711678)
I know you said there are consequences to which one you pick, so we partially agree. But "There is no right or wrong answer" implies all value judgements are purely subjective, that all values are purely subjective. But I think we agree this couldn't be farther from the truth - these values _govern society_ - they affect everyone around us. Choosing bad values is genuinely harmful. Having the value that slavery is okay isn't just subjective, it's harmful and evil. Maybe if you believe slavery is okay, then you might disagree, but it doesn't make you any less objectively wrong. We could get into a big long thing about how this becomes objective, but suffice to say, if people do not want to be owned, and see being owned as harmful to them... then... they are being harmed.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by loeg on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @07:44PM (#46713770)
It really doesn't matter what non-Americans think in this context; only Americans get to vote in American elections. (And additionally, I think you're essentially wrong that American politics is to the "right" of other developed countries in general.)
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @11:11AM (#46707658)
What laws or presidential orders have the US Left done that shows how extreme they are?
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by loeg on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @07:57PM (#46713848)
The US Left doesn't represent a broad enough population to win most national elections; certainly not enough to pass national law. They win local elections in places like SF or Seattle that were Harris +52 (e.g. contrast with Maduro's fake election only claiming a 9 point margin) and are over-represented in Dem party donors, which influences Dem representatives.

Nevertheless, they express extreme positions. Like "people should be treated preferentially by race" or "private property should be abolished/confiscated" or "the police should be defunded" or "transwomen should be allowed to compete in women's sports categories" or "illegal immigrants should receive taxpayer-subsidized healthcare." These are like 70-30 or 80-20 issues at the national level, with Leftists on the wrong side.

https://decidingtowin.org/

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Thursday January 22, 2026 @11:34PM (#46728464)
I asked for policies or laws they have implemented not whether they have expressed extreme views.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by loeg on Friday January 23, 2026 @03:38PM (#46737582)
Ok. I think I adequately answered that. They're a minority faction; they can't pass laws. I think you know this, and your comment suggesting a faction must pass laws in order to be extreme (bluGill's contention) was a deliberate sleight of hand.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Saturday January 24, 2026 @01:26AM (#46741528)
You can also use examples from when their was a Democrat president and Congress was controlled by them.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Saturday January 24, 2026 @01:29AM (#46741535)
> The US Left doesn't represent a broad enough population to win most national elections;

What's your evidence for this?

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Wednesday January 21, 2026 @11:10AM (#46707644)
The Democrats made small progress on healthcare.

Insurers couldn't deny coverage due to existing conditions

Kids could stay on parents until 26 even if they aren't in school

There were also subsidies for the lowest income people to help pay for open market plans.

This is something right? This is a step in the right direction?

If one party wants this and the other wants to dismantle then the first is left and the latter right.

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by viraptor on Friday January 23, 2026 @07:47AM (#46731840)
It's bare minimum. It's "not-right". You don't normally call someone leftist for just saying "people should have access to healthcare without going bankrupt".
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Friday January 23, 2026 @11:42AM (#46734597)
If I said I was going to lose weight and started jogging would you criticize me for doing the bare minimum after my first day?
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by viraptor on Friday January 23, 2026 @05:26PM (#46738832)
If you're still eating doughnuts on the way in this stretched metaphor, yeah, I'd say you're doing the bare minimum.
Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by Braxton1980 on Friday January 23, 2026 @11:43AM (#46734612)
Your use of the bare minimum implies a one time action with no further potential changes.

How do you know that was the case?

Re:Danish pension fund divesting US Treasuries by viraptor on Friday January 23, 2026 @05:23PM (#46738800)
Because it was given up for a promise to talk about it later maybe.