Yes, they may need to do much more activity and eat much less food or in different ratios than others to see results, but that doesn't change the fact that the same algorithm is: 1. the only known way to make progress, 2. well understood.
I was trying to sidestep the very issue (and same old tired conversation) you're trying to avoid: blaming individuals.
Because while it's arguable that a given hypothetical person might be overweight due their own choices and failings, it's next to impossible to argue that massive society-wide changes in health, in a single generation, are simply the result of huge swaths of a society all making the same bad personal decision, all at the same time.
I'm personally a tiny bit incredulous anytime someone mentions that they've tried cutting calories, but with no results. I've always wondered how they continue to get an energy surplus in the absence of input. These seemingly perpetual motion machines would be of great interest to science, I'm sure ;)
Of course, this is why any good diet needs to be coupled with an exercise program.
Even better, increase your caloric intake, switch to a high-protein diet and start lifting some heavy weights. Muscle creation is metabolically expensive, and muscle maintenance uses a lot of calories. Furthermore, even though muscle is heavier than fat (omg you may gain weight!) it looks a lot slimmer and more fit.
Moral of the story: lift weights, eat protein, get fit, lose "mirror" pounds (even if you actually put more mass on)
Example discussion I pulled out of google:
Like doing big-O notation, there are constants that get factored out. Some people have a higher or lower base metabolism, or respond differently to exercise.
You're not proposing, though, that it's possible to maintain or gain weight at a calorie deficit? That would be magical.
That doesn't make it any easier to determine what calories out happens to be for a given person on a given day. It does mean that a reasonable estimate can be made and evaluated against a well tracked dietary intake (but well tracked there has its own set of problems).
HN is a place that may be full of people who's brilliant in their field, which unfortunately #1) has nothing to do with fitness #2) it's correlated with being "not exactly fit", so certainly this is not the right place to establish beliefs in the fitness field.
If it's not true, then not eating shouldn't kill us, and anorexia isn't an illness. Have you tried to stop eating? When I tried to wean myself off food, I lost 12 lbs. I'm completely serious -- I went for a week without solid food, taking in only 32oz of soda and 24oz of beer per day (while not working).
I'm absolutely convinced that you would get an adequate fit starting to study very "standard" nutrition books and understanding what you're doing.
"Losing weight" is a concept that must be absolutely removed. Boxers for example lose a couple of kg in a very short time before being weighted for matches. Does this mean they successfully got a better shape? No. Study, and you will understand how things work.
"Losing weight" was absolutely necessary for me, and it will be for most people -- unless you're suggesting that humans can be healthy at 5'11" and 260lbs, or 5'5" and 210lbs -- but that seems too unrealistic.
What I learned of nutrition (after that experiment) taught me that most of what's in bread, pasta, fruit, etc is cruft. Most "health" food is just more empty calories in a "healthier" package.
From reading discussions and articles about it that pop up here from time to time, and also from talking with my family and friends, I'd disagree. What I actually perceive is that in discussions about loosing weight:
- a) people generalize personal anecdotes,
- b) there are dozens of popular diets, and people usually quote their favourite,
- c) whatever Real Science gets quoted, will soon be challenged by another paper saying something opposite,
- d) people try to reason from common sense ("surely if you eat less X you'll be less fat, because X does this-and-that"); I was a believer of the thermodynamics-like theory that deltaWeight = weight + (calories in - calories out)*stuff; many a post on HN convinced me that it's not true, even though it sounds much more obvious than typical dietetary nonsense you'll hear from your random friend.
I'm against blaming everything on people being not determined or hardworking enough. For one, it's wrong attitude (any system that assumes strong willpower or moral high ground from people will fail because of human nature; it's better to engineer around it), and secondly, there are indications that the same diet/exercise combination executed with the same determination will have great effects on some, moderate on others, and zero-to-negative on few unfortunate people.