News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:10AM (#4668799)
Your two assertions that

1. Eating healthily is more expensive than eating junk

2. Eating poorly impairs your ability to think to the extent that you cannot be held responsible for your poor choice of diet

I find them very hard to believe (even though I hear them often). Do you have any links to the studies or evidence that show this?

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by rdl on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:44AM (#4668983)
If you live in the ghetto (where shopping options are corner stores or equivalent, not cheap hippie coops) and have no time (due to kids, poor time management, long hours at a low paying job, ...), don't have a real kitchen or any skills, etc., it is a lot harder to eat healthy and cheaply.

The first part of #2 is true, but the latter part is more a moral or philosophical question.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by skylan_q on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:13AM (#4668816)
"Eating healthily is more expensive than eating junk"

This assertion is blatantly false. I can get full on excellent quality food for about the price of a mcdonald's meal + a bag of chips.

I've eaten like crap, and I've eaten well. It's very cheap to eat healthy. Most people are just making excuses for not wanting to practice self-control or educate themselves.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by potatolicious on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:55AM (#4669048)
Spoken like a person of privilege - a widespread epidemic clearly must be hordes of poor people too lazy to exercise self-control.

Having lived in both incredibly poor neighborhoods and incredibly wealthy ones, I'll say this:

It's possible to eat healthily in poor neighborhoods, it takes a lot of work - a lot more work than it does for a wealthy person living in a wealthy place. I've observed this in myself: I gained enormous amounts of weight while living in a poor, working-class neighborhood, and promptly shed it once I moved to a wealthy upper middle-class neighborhood. I've bounced back and forth between poor areas and rich areas since then, and the pattern has so far held up.

But, anecdotes not equivalent to data, etc etc.

In a upper-middle class neighborhood healthy diets practically come after you with a baseball bat. It's steeped in the general consciousness of the area, support by people who possess the freedom of finance, time, and effort to think about such things, and it's supported by the merchants in the area.

The same is not true in poor neighborhoods, where fast is king to a population of overworked and tired people. When you're holding down multiple jobs and raising kids at the same time, the CSA subscription may be cheaper and healthier, but it also requires time you don't have. Merchant offerings in the area reflect this reality, and so even someone with the intent to eat healthily will find that availability of healthy food is substantially lower.

We are fortunate in that we have the resources with which to abstract many annoying details away from our lives so we can concentrate on the important things: good bodily health, mental well-being, and the such. Most of the population isn't so lucky.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by mhartl on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:43AM (#4669289)
Did poor people 100 years ago have the same problem? I doubt it. But today, poor people in America are fatter than rich people. Fat poor people? There's something strange going on here...
Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by potatolicious on Thursday October 18, 2012 @12:19PM (#4669463)
> "Fat poor people?"

This seems only incredible because you don't understand the mechanics of being poor.

Contrary to popular belief, the main bottleneck of being poor is not access to food - the market has solved that part remarkably well, and farming improvements throughout the last century (Borlaug is perhaps rolling in his grave) means that food in general is so cheap that everyone in a developed country has access to it.

The main bottleneck of being poor is time.

A poor person spends considerably more time just to ensure survival than a wealthy person, and has remarkably little "disposable" time remaining in a day. Long, irregular hours, possibility of multiple jobs, lack of access to speedy/on-demand transportation, lack of access to time-creating conveniences (laundromat far way instead of laundry in the house, for example), all serve to make time the rarest resource for the poor.

That's not an exhaustive list by the way, and I don't pretend to know the full exhaustive list.

All of this means that the poor gravitates towards fast, low-effort food, and the rest makes sense.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by mhartl on Thursday October 18, 2012 @03:37PM (#4670643)
If poor people can be fat, we need a different word for what people 100 years ago would have called "poor". Maybe "destitute" could serve this purpose?

In any case, if you're poor, your time is cheap. This doesn't jibe with the claim that the poor lack enough time to, say, cook healthy meals for themselves. Poor people 100 years ago were poorer than most poor people today, and yet they largely cooked for themselves—and they were much thinner.

What accounts for this change? My suspicion is that it's dependence without responsibility. A hundred years ago, private charities (which are accountable to their donors) were in a position to hold recipients of their largesse responsible for their actions. But such charities have now largely been displaced by government agencies. These agencies have been captured by special interest groups,† and charity has mutated into entitlements. As a result of receiving benefits without accountability, the poor have lost much of the knowledge needed to be self-sufficient, which motivates further intervention. It's the law of unintended consequences followed by iatrogenic escalation.

†These interest groups are not the poor themselves, but rather those who speak for the poor. I think it's no coincidence that the former tend to vote for the latter. Political patronage is one of the oldest plays in the book.

I'd guess you'll find the above narrative unconvincing, but I like how you think, so I thought it was worth a shot.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:12AM (#4669129)
Is obesity/overweightness worse in the poorer demographics than it is in the middle and upper classes? (rather than just more counter-intuitive)
Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by potatolicious on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:20AM (#4669167)
Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:19AM (#4668846)
> This assertion is blatantly false. I can get full on excellent quality food for about the price of a mcdonald's meal + a bag of chips.

Not that kind of junk. Think ramen noodles.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by tryitnow on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:50AM (#4669329)
"Most people are just making excuses for not wanting to practice self-control or educate themselves."

This is true, but not a very useful thing to say. Trivial observations of others' moral failings are often a way for us to feel better about ourselves and our choices, but such statements are not solving the problem.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by kijin on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:34AM (#4668925)
A lot of people can't even afford a mcdonald's meal + a bag of chips.

Everywhere I look, fat is cheaper than protein, white bread is cheaper than whole-grain multigrain bread, white rice is cheaper than brown rice, a pack of sugar is cheaper than the same weight in fresh fruits and veggies, and a bottle of sauce made with nothing but salt and MSG is cheaper than a bottle of sauce made with natural ingredients. When you need to feed 2 teenagers with a budget of single-digit dollars per day, every penny counts.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @10:39AM (#4668957)
Is it also cheaper to get overweight/obese on unhealthy food than consume just enough calories of healthy foodstuffs?
Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by kijin on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:08AM (#4669109)
Assume that unhealthy food is $1/serving and 500kcal/serving.

Assume that healthy food is $2/serving and 400kcal/serving.

Assume that you need 2000kcal/day.

A healthy diet costs $10 for "just enough calories". An unhealthy diet costs only $4 for the same calories. If you ate 3000kcal/day, it would still only cost $6. So yes, it can be cheaper to eat a lot of unhealthy food than to eat only a small amount of healthy food if the price differential is large enough. It's also easier to overdose on unhealthy food because the calories are so concentrated. A second bowl of ramen can contain 400 calories. A second head of lettuce might only have 40 calories.

Of course, you might face a million-dollar loss 20 years later because of heart disease, but would it really enter the calculations of a single mom with a weekly grocery budget of $35?

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by eru on Friday October 19, 2012 @10:25AM (#4673630)
You can get protein for really cheap. You just have to get used to eating offal.
Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by mistercow on Thursday October 18, 2012 @11:21AM (#4669170)
>Eating poorly impairs your ability to think to the extent that you cannot be held responsible for your poor choice of diet

You appear to have fallen into the trap of believing that the concepts of compassion and personal responsibility are at odds with each other. American politics have been poisoned by the same idea, and it's a real shame.

Re:Overweight people are now a global problem by Tycho on Thursday October 18, 2012 @12:14PM (#4669439)
Depends if you believe

Judge not, so that ye shall not be judged

Vs.

Judge, and expect to be judged