News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by tsotha on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:35AM (#4667705)
I'm pretty sure this kind of thing doesn't make governments nervous. For one thing, they can always place a virus or a bug on your phone. Or they can do it the old fashioned way and bug your car/office/bedroom.

This will only going defeat the "dragnet" type stuff that combs through millions of conversations looking for keywords. I guess that's something, but if you've managed to attract the all-seeing eye you shouldn't be lulled into a false sense of security because the link between your mobile and someone else's is secure.

Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by TeMPOraL on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:48AM (#4668190)
Yes, but the "dragnet" type stuff is the more important one. If you "attract the all-seeing eye" to the point of getting personal attention (being hacked or physically bugged), it means that government already has more than enough reasons to get rid of you and nothing can keep you safe from an AGM-114 flying through the window and/or enough red-tape being unleashed on you to make you die in misery. They probably just need some information from you to go after someone else.

On the other hand, mass-scale surveillance enables you to actually find targets of interest out of sea of people irrelevant to the case. Because the usual problem is, you know there are Bad Guys[0] out there, but you don't know where. Mass-surveillance makes the search much, much less expensive. So they really care about it.

And there's also an issue of Big Data, aka. whatever data they collect on people can in the future be used in a ways we can't even imagine now but won't like when it happens. So the data itself is also a danger. Also humans make mistakes, and algorithms are not always good, and no one would like to have their home raided because some long-forgotten bayesian filter buried deep in the system didn't use logarithms properly and introduced serious errors to probability computations. That's why people care.

[0] - relative to what govt. sees as bad at the moment.

Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by dthunt on Thursday October 18, 2012 @02:53AM (#4667732)
There are big concerns with mobile phones, especially with the radio baseband. I'm reluctant to consider phones genuinely 'secure' until the radio doesn't have access to the user OS or non-radio related hardware, and the microphone and sensitive storage is physically separated from the phone.
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by fab13n on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:15AM (#4668013)
> if you've managed to attract the all-seeing eye [...]

But I guess that governments expect large-scale surveillance to be the primary way to attract the all-seeing eye.

National security was done a certain way during the cold war, when facing highly organized intelligence services. The swarms of nutjobs, loosely herd by amorphous terrorist organizations, are much harder to detect; many people probably have high hopes about big data and statistical methods to find them.

Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by mogrim on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:06AM (#4668109)
They can also just legislate you out of existence: "You want to operate here? You comply with the law. And that means a backdoor."

As long as this service is commercial (which apparently it is) it will have a payment gateway, and that point can be easily blocked by a local government.

Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by Vivtek on Thursday October 18, 2012 @06:45AM (#4668187)
So everybody but the United States will have secure communications. Race to the bottom, then? The place seems more Soviet every day.
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by tsotha on Thursday October 18, 2012 @12:30PM (#4669510)
The US has a lot more influence in these kinds of things than you would think. I'm continually amazed at how easily countries buckle when faced with, for example, financial industry sanctions. Look at the way copyright law has changed over the years.
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has... by Vivtek on Friday October 19, 2012 @09:48AM (#4673476)
Ouch - point taken.