Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has...
by zwass on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @10:23PM
(#4667209)
The problem is, anyone who is serious about security is going to need to read the source and compile the binary they load onto their phone. Nontechnical people aren't going to be able to do that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has...
by hollerith on Thursday October 18, 2012 @05:23AM
(#4668031)
A tech guy can ask a non-tech guy if he can examine his phone. If the binary on the phone differs from any binary the tech guy can get by compiling clean source code, he can raise questions. This is how a group of tech guys who are in communication with each other can protect the privacy of a much larger population of non-tech guys.
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has...
by xyzzy123 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:13AM
(#4668244)
Right; if you don't understand the technology (or like most of us, haven't taken the time to comprehensively review it) you have to rely on social proof.
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has...
by xyzzy123 on Thursday October 18, 2012 @07:12AM
(#4668238)
Thinking about this really hard, I'm not sure how nontechnical people can ever be sure that they can trust technical artifacts?
Re:New "Surveillance-Proof" App To Secure Communications Has...
by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @10:33PM
(#4667235)
Well with those two sentences you've pretty much ensured that this is never, ever possible. You'd have to have a trust system from the silicon up, signed bootloader, hypervisor, no exploits, etc to guarantee that the system you're booting is executing the binaries you think it is.
At some point "good enough" has to be enough. Okay, you built the APK, how do you know I don't control the VM and just swap out that JIT'd method with one that I've altered? (Repeat this until you get all the way back to the initial power-up)