News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: The Analog I – Inducing Recursive Self-Modeling ... by hhh on Friday January 16, 2026 @01:43PM (#46650222)
adding a scratch space for an llm to fill up and then ‘review’ (no better term for this) and using it to drive the final output isn’t new and it isn’t more than good prompting
Re:Show HN: The Analog I – Inducing Recursive Self-Modeling ... by Phil_BoaM on Friday January 16, 2026 @01:56PM (#46650470)
Totally fair. I'm not claiming to have invented the concept of a 'scratchpad' or Chain-of-Thought. In that sense, yes, it is 'just' prompt engineering.

But the distinction is in the architecture of that scratchpad.

Most CoT prompts are linear ('Let's think step by step'). This protocol is adversarial. It uses the scratchpad to simulate a split where the model must actively reject its own first draft (which is usually sycophantic) before outputting the final response.

It’s less about a new mechanism and more about applying a specific cognitive structure to solve a specific problem (Sycophancy/Slop). If 'good prompting' can make a base model stop hallucinating just to please the user, I'll call it a win.