News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by cjbprime on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @07:55PM (#4662545)
Untrue.

> By contrast, pipes, sockets and command-line arguments are communication mechanisms normally used between two separate programs. So when they are used for communication, the modules normally are separate programs. - http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html

Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by vlasta2 on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @08:15PM (#4662620)
Agree, but I think the GPL examples about communication mechanisms are pretty weird and sometimes absurd. Consider this scenario:

Someone takes a GIMP plug-in licensed under GPL and converts it to a Photoshop plug-in (which is a DLL and shares memory space with Photoshop).

According to GPL, Photoshop would now have to be open-sourced, but the person, who converted the plug-in does not have access to Photoshop source code.

What now? Goes GPL actually forbids the existence of this? What if the converted plug-in with the source code is published? Is that actually illegal? What if they only publish the adapted source code and not the binary? What if a third person compiles it and publishes the binary? Who would be the guilty party?

Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by flomo on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @08:39PM (#4662685)
I've followed GPL discussions from the sidelines for sometime, and whenever someone comes up with a 'trick' scenario like this, the standard advice is "if you'd like to do that, call your lawyer".

(The legal definition of 'derived works' is based in case law and is more complex than what you'd find in a FSF FAQ.)

Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by aidenn0 on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @01:43AM (#4663294)
IANAL, but: Distributing a photoshop plugin containing GPL code is a violation of the GPL as it is worded. If that part of the GPL is enforcable (no precedent that I am aware of) then you would essentially be pirating the GPL code, and can be sued for monetary damages by the owner of the copyright for that code.
Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by lutusp on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @01:53AM (#4663315)
> Distributing a photoshop plugin containing GPL code is a violation of the GPL as it is worded.

That would only be true if the distributor failed to provide the source code to any interested party who asked for it. If he met that requirement, and if he included all the original copyright notices in the source along with his own, there's no violation.

Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by aidenn0 on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @02:22AM (#4663372)
The source code to photoshop?
Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by callahad on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @08:03PM (#4662576)
For even greater emphasis: the FSF has a vested interest in promoting a maximally broad interpretation of the GPL. It's not legal advice, but when even their own FAQ says you're in the clear, you're likely to be pretty damn "safe."
Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by pjscott on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @08:21PM (#4662645)
The FSF wants the GPL to be a license that people will actually use, and within that constraint, they want it to be interpreted in a way that most strictly protects software freedom, as they see it. If they just wanted it to be as broad as possible, they would be shooting themselves in the feet; it's easy for ticked-off software creators to switch to a less restrictive license if they own the copyright to software under the GPL.

This, for example, is why the FSF always mentions explicitly that they do not consider merely using a tool like grep as part of a shell script to be a derived work. They have to be reasonable, or they lose their power.

Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by sigzero on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @07:57PM (#4662551)
There is no way on God's green Earth that you can say his product is a derived work of GNU grep because it is used in the way he describes. At the very least, they just have to provide the source for grep.
Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by kstrauser on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @07:54PM (#4662542)
That's a unique interpretation of the GPL shared by no one else I've ever talked to.
Re:GNU grep - A Cautionary Tale About GPLv3 by rbanffy on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @11:08PM (#4663008)
There are some guys at Microsoft that would probably want people to interpret the GPL in the scariest way possible.

I've met many during my career.