News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teaching linear algebra by jmduke on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @03:30PM (#4661444)
(Disclaimer: I am a current college student.)

I took a seminar on Film Studies my freshman year (all freshmen are required to take a seminar outside of their prospective major). We watched exactly one film -- Psycho -- which I greatly admired. That being said, I can't tell you much about the theory behind Psycho; but I can tell you pages upon pages about the evolution and use of 90mm film.

The results in the blog post speak for themselves; the final exam scores were phenomenal.

That being said, I feel the author didn't spend enough time dwelling on the repercussions of his approach to the course. If you're in a two- or three-credit class, you take that class with the implicit understanding course that the time commitment is going to be similar to that of other classes; if your students are spending all night working on an introductory class, then they might master that material -- but at the expense of other classes.

I took a Linear Algebra course last semester that I did well in. It was a conventional class. I definitely couldn't answer that final bonus question (and I bet I couldn't answer most of the questions on that exam) but is that an issue? Introductory courses are meant to be breadth-based, not depth-based; my class wasn't filled with Math majors but CS majors, Chem majors, Stats majors, etc. etc. -- I recognize the huge role tenets of L.A. play in programming, but I'd absolutely resent a professor who essentially uses false advertising in his course.

The metric for a successful college course, I'd argue, is not 'amount learned' but 'amount learned with respect to time and respect to the goals of the course.'

Re:Teaching linear algebra by naner on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @03:39PM (#4661477)
my class wasn't filled with Math majors but CS majors, Chem majors, Stats majors

I don't know much about chemistry, but for CS and stats people linear algebra is an applicable and important course. Some of these "introductary" courses are foundational to your degree.

Re:Teaching linear algebra by jmduke on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @05:27PM (#4661952)
Absolutely! I remember the basics of linear algebra very well, and can reproduce them easily -- proofs and more arcane aspects of the curriculum, on the other hand, not so much. (Furthermore, I'd argue that the average non-Math major is not going to have to apply such aspects, and thus an introductory course should be relatively cursory regarding them.)
Re:Teaching linear algebra by infinite8s on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @01:20PM (#4665493)
Linear algebra is pretty important when you start doing quantum chemistry (usually an upper level undergraduate/intro level graduate class).