In a free Heroku instance you have a lot of juice actually, especially for an Nginx server, the only problem being that the instance will go in idle mode after an hour of inactivity and so unlucky visitors can get some latency on the first request, although it's not that awful.
On the other hand CloudFlare is a pretty good proxy that works like a CDN, so with the right caching headers set, CloudFlare will serve many requests from its own cache.
If you strive for geek cred, you can get
> Your website is faster than 100% of all tested websites
The trick is to 1. have a static website, obviously, and everything inlined (so basically a single index.html); 2. run the test twice — dns responses should cache during the first one; 3. host your website in Amsterdam which is where they have (at least one of) their testers:
> Tested from Amsterdam, Netherlands on October 16 at 19:04:21
Oh, and don't use SSL.
Pingdom is kind of nifty for its comparisons. I got the author's site to be only in the top 97% by running the benchmark again. My own site varies from being in the top 90% to 96% (I did get a 99% once), the only real "optimization" I do is reading cached pages from "disk" (EBS is notoriously pretty slow). I could probably shave off an average 100ms with some really simple tricks. Under heavy load I'm certain I'd fall over on such a puny machine that isn't even using nginx+memcached.