News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by drivebyacct2 on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:06PM (#4658143)
Why do people love to act like both parties are the same? Is it just errant, broad pessimism?

I understand wanting more options or not liking either available option but they're not the same. They don't have the same values, beliefs, principles, policies or experiences. They have many things in common, but they're not the same and it's not useless to talk about them and their perception in the polls.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by justin66 on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @01:29AM (#4658564)
> Why do people love to act like both parties are the same? Is it just errant, broad pessimism?

On the contrary, it's not necessarily pessimism, the people who feel that way are probably just rather focused on the issues where the candidates are depressingly similar. For example if you want to see military spending massively reduced, the financial system reformed in fundamental ways to reduce systemic risk, or massively increased gasoline taxes to cover infrastructure improvements or green energy development, you probably feel badly served by both parties and their candidates right now.

On the other hand, if you're a gay man who wants to get married and start a family, or a redneck who wants to be able to carry your .357 magnum wherever you want whenever you want, or a rich guy who wants to keep your taxes as close to zero as can be achieved under the current two party system, the party differences are rather more obvious to you.

It's not really a question of pessimism, just the way people prioritize things. A person who has a lot of strong interests in the first category of issues (where the parties are rather similar, or just similarly useless) might be a lot more likely to say the parties are the same than a person whose strong interests are in the other set of issues.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by antoko on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:24PM (#4658191)
Not that I speak for the GP but for me personally it is a question of relative similarity. My values compared to either one of the two main US parties are very different. Given that the relative similarities of the two parties it means they are effectively "the same".

If I instead compare and contrast them with each other, obviously I can too can see that they are not "the same"

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by jeffool on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @01:54AM (#4658601)
I've come to see people saying that as "they are the same in areas I particularly care about." Now, what those similar areas are, is usually the same. Corporate influence. (Usually, anyway. It can change.)

The importance of those similar areas to other people is unaddressed in this concern. Key is that the opinion holder see this as a larger issue in their, or everyone's lives, even if others (you, me, anyone) may disagree.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by colanderman on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:37PM (#4658219)
If they weren't similar, then it would behoove them to become more so, lest the other party move to sway undecided voters.

Plurality voting ensures that there are two major parties, and that they are as similar as possible without ceding ground to third parties.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by ryanwaggoner on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:59PM (#4658270)
The big risk isn't 3rd parties, it's just not voting, as about half of our citizens decide to do. And for example, it's hard to see the Republican party try to capture undecided voters with more centrist policies without pissing off the right-wing portion of their party, who won't go vote for the green party, but will instead:

1) Not vote 2) Start something like the Tea Party 3) Toss the incumbents out because they weren't extreme enough

This is happening on the left as well; we're becoming way more partisan as a country, and slowly but surely removing all the moderates from Congress.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by pc86 on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @09:48AM (#4659815)
Half is optimistic. In non-presidential year congressional elections it's not uncommon to have less than 1 in 3 voting. In true off-year elections in odd years where most folks are voting on lower court judges (in my state, anyway), local representatives on councils and school boards, it's much closer to 1 in 5 or less.

There are just over 600 people in my ward of my township. 67 people voted in 2011 for the Council seat that was up. It's disgusting.

I would posit that the cause is somewhat different, though: the partisan zealots are the ones that vote in every single primary and general election. For those of you who vote for POTUS and that's all, there are actually two elections every year. The country as a whole I think is more moderate than 99% of our elected officials, but the country as a whole isn't voting. It's largely straight-ticket people voting, especially in off years. This results in Members of Congress becoming more extreme because those are the people voting for them.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by antoko on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @05:07PM (#4661847)
I'm not sure how much of this is actually due to voter apathy. Whilst I agree with promoting civic engagement it may not directly address this issue.

The reason the country is becoming more partisan is more likely due to the benefits of incumbency, and the insane level of gerrymandering we allow. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering#United_States

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by andreasvc on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:59PM (#4658272)
The GP didn't say that they're the same, just that they're in the hands of corporations. Now that may or may not be true, but I think it's obvious that a two party state is very sub-optimal.
Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by elsurudo on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:25PM (#4658194)
The point isn't that they're "the same". It's that they're the same _where it matters_.

That they are both bought and paid for by the same corporate money. Where do the hundreds of millions to fund the campaigns come from? You don't think that those interests might, you know, want something in return?

All mainstream political "discussion" is simply a distraction from the true issues. To think anything else is just naive.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by drivebyacct2 on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:37PM (#4658221)
>It's that they're the same _where it matters_.

Quite frankly, that's bullshit. Romney/Ryan advocate a rollback of my rights and continued (or furthered) discrimination against me. That's only one small social issue that they differ on and they differ on policies that involve much more substantive issues.

Maybe you're privileged or fortunate enough to not be affected by tax rates, women's rights legislation, gay rights issues, and more, but many of us aren't. Those issues matter and that's why some support Romney and some support Obama.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by psbp on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @12:35AM (#4658467)
It's really frustrating to see how often they're described as the same thing. Whenever there's just one (or a couple of) issues that diverge from someone's personal opinion, they completely disregard all of the differences. I can accept that there's a lot of grey area in politics. That doesn't completely shroud the very distinct differences there would be between a Romney and Obama administration.
Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by wrathsu on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @02:14PM (#4661096)
What rights did you gain under the Obama administration that you would lose under a Romney administration? How would Romney discriminate against you in a way that Obama would not?
Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @03:41PM (#4661490)
DADT? Soon to include DOMA? Federal benefits for domestic partners. That's only on gay rights.

How clueless are people about social issues exactly?

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by marshallp on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:45PM (#4658240)
I wouldn't consider those really substantive compared to drawback of the military-industrial complex, radical increase in nasa/science funding, full free national health-care (including dentistry), overhaul of the education system (along the lines advocated by khan academy), ending the drug war, ending corporate welfare (and maybe even corporate personhood), and probably other major ones I can't think of right now.
Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by drivebyacct2 on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:53PM (#4658253)
Those issues affect me every, single day in a tangible primary fashion. The other problems, yes, are frustrating. Romney and Obama differ on how the feel towards funding that military industrial complex, and in a telling way given what you're discussing and the nature of the industrial complex.

As for national health-care, education, science, etc, they very noticeably and very starkly differ as well.

... I feel like you just supported what I was saying. My second post was simply an example of how they differ in meaningful ways.

Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by andreasvc on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @12:05AM (#4658410)
This is not an either/or discussion. I see what you mean, that there is a very tangible difference between the current two candidates. On the other hand, two is a very limited choice. A lot of first world countries have multi-party systems and have some form of social democracy. Perhaps if it weren't for the first-past-the-post electoral system, the US might be a social democracy as well.
Re:FiveThirtyEight: Over the Decades, How States Have Shifted by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @12:37AM (#4658473)
>On the other hand, two is a very limited choice.

Oh I certainly agree.