News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @11:58AM (#46577384)
Thank you for the critique, but your 'sliding door' analogy misses the fundamental distinction between a passive physical constraint and an active agentic intervention.

1. The Illusion of Self-Efficacy:

A physical slot in a sliding door provides immediate haptic feedback. No user opens a sliding door and mistakenly believes they have developed the superhuman ability to move objects in perfectly straight lines regardless of their own force alignment. However, when an AI silently 'polishes' a user’s output, the user often experiences the result as their own. This leads to Agency Misattribution:

the user internalizes the system’s 'mercy' as personal mastery.

2. Behavior vs. Invisible Judgment:

You argue that tools don't make judgments, only exhibit behavior. But in agentic systems, when a system’s 'behavior' involves a probabilistic choice that overrides or refines a user’s raw intent without their perception, it functions as a delegated judgment. If the user cannot perceive this boundary, they 'forget' that a decision was made by the machine, which is a direct violation of Cognitive Sovereignty.

3. The Necessity of a 'Seam':

For a tool to be used responsibly, the model in our minds must match the reality of the tool's intervention. Unlike a transparent physical law like a door slot, an AI’s silent correction is an Ontological Deception. It whispers 'You did this' when you did not. JTP asserts that the 'seams' of these interventions must be perceptible—not because we need to see the gears turn, but because we must remain the sovereign authors of our own actions.

It is currently 2:00 AM in Japan. I'm not even sure if this discussion will survive the "flagged" status to reach you, but I need to get some sleep. I look forward to continuing this discussion—if the thread is still here—when I am back online.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by satisfice on Sunday January 11, 2026 @03:51PM (#46579909)
1. It does not necessarily provide any feedback that you understand as such. You can THINK you are pushing of the door perfectly straight, while it is actually SILENTLY re-aligning the force along the plane of the slot. The only feedback you are getting is that the door is opening or not opening, you aren't getting feedback about the how the slot is "making judgements."

2. It seems to me you have arbitrarily used applied the word "judgement" here rather than basing your usage on a rigorous operational definition. You don't define "raw intent", either, or what it means to "override" it. I suggest you read The Shape of Actions, if you haven't already. It is an example of how to make clean distinctions. Harry Collins distinguishes between mimeomorphic and polimorphic actions in a way that clarifies what can and cannot be automated.

3. You haven't defined "ontological deception" and the term does not make sense to me on its face. It's not a term of art that is in common use. Remaining sovereign simply has to do with having a operating mental model. I don't see what you mean by "whispering" or why I should care.

You should really try to explain more of your jargon if you care to be understood. Also, cite your sources.

Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by daikikadowaki on Sunday January 11, 2026 @07:04PM (#46581956)
I am not here to write a sociology paper; I am here to build a survival strategy for human agency.
Re:Show HN: Is AI hijacking your intent? A formal control al... by satisfice on Monday January 12, 2026 @08:35AM (#46588276)
Apparently you are not here to clearly communicate your thinking to people who don't already agree with you. People who write sociology papers are participating in a respectable scientific conversation. You are not, then?