The linked post contains three cases of Markdown syntax (underscores) leaking into the text, where actual italics were likely intended. This is the most basic Markdown syntax element failing to work. The problem CommonMark is trying to solve is not adding new features (the only one they added to Gruber Markdown is fenced code blocks), but rather specifying how to interpret edge cases to ensure the same Markdown code produces the same HTML everywhere.
I understand the goal of the spec. In my experience once some spec document gets adapted widely enough, there's a strong incentive to add new features to it, which renderers would then be compelled to implement. Before you know it, MD is a complicated spec that doesn't serve its original purpose.
In this case a few minor edge cases is really not a big deal compared to that (in my opinion).
Re:How Markdown Took over the World
by janwillemb on Saturday January 10, 2026 @09:09AM
(#46565852)
Here is a post from Atwood about it:
https://blog.codinghorror.com/standard-markdown-is-now-commo...
And an interesting discussion on hn about it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4700383
I am not sure (of course), but I think Atwood simply thought standardizing this format was so obviously valuable that he didn't consider Gruber might not want to work with him. In retrospect it's kind of nice that it didn't happen, it really keeps everyone incentivized to keep the format simple.