Re:Texas A&M bans part of Plato's Symposium
by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @05:12PM
(#46533836)
Academics absolutely do have fruitful arguments about religion and politics. Pretending that there is nothing to learn is just anti-intellectualism.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Texas A&M bans part of Plato's Symposium
by foster_nyman on Wednesday January 07, 2026 @06:18PM
(#46534647)
You’re right, and I agree wholeheartedly: academics absolutely do have fruitful arguments about religion and politics.
I read Graham’s point as narrower than “there’s nothing to learn.” He explicitly says: “There are certainly some political questions that have definite answers.”
The warning label is about identity capture. Once a view becomes part of who you are, the odds of real updating drop: “people can never have a fruitful argument about something that’s part of their identity.” Or, put positively: “you can have a fruitful discussion … so long as you exclude people who respond from identity.”
So the issue isn’t the topic. It’s what happens when belief turns into a kind of badge.