I agree, that is a good point. Although it is (induced) subgraphs of 2D grids, which gets you a bit closer to the planar case (albeit with bounded degree).
It might be polytime on planar graphs, but that would be surprising.
It might be polytime on planar graphs, but that would be surprising.
Is NP hardness proven for just planar graphs? Those are closer to the 2D grid, but still slightly more general. All I could find was a reduction to densest k subgraphs, but Wikipedia tells me that whether that problem is NP hard for planar graphs is an open question.
To be clear, I would be very surprised if the problem turns out to be _not_ NP hard, but there is no trivial equivalence to min cut in general graphs to show that it is.