News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Observations on what's getting downvoted, with some disse... by Stratoscope on Sunday October 14, 2012 @03:43PM (#4652376)
I'm closing in on that magical 500 karma number where I hear that I'll start to see downvote buttons. I'm almost hoping there is a way I can opt out of this and not have those buttons appear.

Why? The ridiculous system here that gives you one shot at hitting the right button with no chance to correct your mistake. I've seen too many comments saying, "Sorry, I was trying to upvote your comment and fat-fingered the downvote button by mistake." I often read HN on my phone or a tablet and it will be all too easy for me to do that.

Reddit, for all its flaws, gets this right. If you tap the wrong button or change your mind, perhaps after realizing that you misunderstood something, you can fix it.

Re:Observations on what's getting downvoted, with some disse... by jiggy2011 on Sunday October 14, 2012 @04:52PM (#4652609)
I have experienced the same problem myself. An even simpler (partial) fix would be to just move the buttons further away from each other. They are so close at the moment that hitting the right one on a touch device is basically pure luck. You could also use JS to add an "are you sure?" popup upon hitting downvote.

OTOH HN actually has a fair number of usability issues, though it doesn't seem like there is much interest in fixing them (I'm sure PG has plenty of other things to do). I think this might be partly because this board is written in some form of LISP so less people will be comfortable tweaking the source.

Would it be heresy to suggest a re-implementation in something like rails, or gasp even PHP?

Re:Observations on what's getting downvoted, with some disse... by spindritf on Sunday October 14, 2012 @08:48PM (#4653184)
> with no chance to correct your mistake

Your mistake will result in someone losing a point on a website. Sure, it would be better if you could fix that but it's not a big deal.

You can make truly catastrophic mistakes everyday driving a car or even pushing an update. On HN other users can easily rectify minor slip-ups like that.

A much worse mistake is upvoting crap. That is really damaging to the site.