I think you're greatly exaggerating the tendency of technical people to value accuracy and truth over personal opinions. In my experience, people who are technical also tend to have very strong opinions about everything, especially if the subject is technical in nature.
>>The structure of the communities only allows highly valued members to down vote... Here on HN, you must have quite a bit of karma (I think ~500 these days) before you can down vote.
500 karma is really easy to accumulate. All one has to do is conform with popular opinion, and for an active poster it would take a month or so. I was under 500 karma recently, and I kept thinking to myself how much easier it would have been if I had posted in threads about controversial topics and just agreed with everyone. If I had sided with Samsung for example, and spouted the popular (but wrong) opinion that the decision hurts innovation.
What would be the value of karma gained that way? (I mean value for myself - is there any value in being a phony??)
When (or if) I can downvote is not very interesting either - so far I get a lot of great content from HN - like valuable book recommendations. Karma won't make it any better.
What I'd like is HN to remain a good source of information for as long as possible, since I am still finding lot of great info. Karma could help that, but would require an activate participation on my behalf (like clicking for downvoting - consider I rarely highvote, odds are it won't be very useful to me)
Just yesterday I saw a post of mine get voted below - 4 for just questioning the interest of an approach - I first tried to explain how, in my sense, the proposed approach was wrong, gave an example, then basically gave up - not because of the karma but because there are better things to do with one's time.
Everytime there is a score, we humans want to try and max it out. It's a natural tendency, but not always for the better- sometimes thinking whether it might be worth it helps :-)
Karma on HN seems especially worthless. You quickly see who's posting sense and who's not - for ex I didn't need to see the user actual score to consider yummyfajitas posts very interesting and worth spending time to read
...
* If I had sided with Samsung for example, and spouted the popular (but wrong) opinion that the decision hurts innovation.*
Irony.
That aside, voting systems by design favor majority opinion. From the few stories that discuss it, the behind the scenes moderation that goes on here is likely the differentiating factor in comment quality from sites like reddit. The ability to down vote only after participating in the community for a while is just one of many heuristics for moderating the community.
It's more complicated than that. Different voting systems lead to different outcomes, even with the same voters. Just compare discussions on here or reddit with answers on stackexchange.
Though of course, you might chalk that up under the heading of moderation.
Certain (small!) subreddits have these places matched, if not beat.
The key word is small: Once the community grows to become a true microcosm of Reddit, which is a microcosm of a good bit of the English-language Internet, it becomes cat pictures and memes as far as the eye can see because that is what most people want. Individuals decry it, but there is no single countervailing force big enough to do anything about it except, you know, start a new (small!) subreddit.
So /r/politics is a hole but /r/sex is a good place for adult discussions about human sexuality.
(The only alternative to big-is-banal is a very active group of dedicated moderators empowered to remove posts and ban users. This seems to be hated by a lot of people but, dammit, it works.)
I also recall that Slashdot used to be a lot bigger and more important as a news aggregator.
1. The cultures of the communities are largely technical, which is a culture that tends to care more about accuracy and truth, rather than just how closely a comment hews to personal opinions. It's okay to disagree if you present reasonably worthwhile support in the post.
2. The structure of the communities only allows highly valued members to down vote. On Slashdot all moderation (up or down) is controlled by the karma system, and metamoderation "watches the watchers". Here on HN, you must have quite a bit of karma (I think ~500 these days) before you can down vote.
Compare to Reddit, which in most subreddits probably the worst quality moderation I've ever seen in a community. Unpopular truths are downvoted to oblivion, and lies rise to the top if they validate popularly held beliefs. The only exception that comes to mind is /r/askscience, which sets a very high bar to comment at all--all answers must be presented by proven experts or contain references to scientific publications.