I've been using the same technique to test a market and have been struggling to figure out how shady this is. One on hand, it does feel like we're deceiving people, on the other hand, what we're doing is actually benficial to consumers. If they signed up, that means they want what it is that you're trying to build and they're letting you know it.
Only the second is a real test of if the idea is valuable and viable. This way you end with with a 'hot' mailing list. You also can't worry about losing these early potential clients, if your client pool is really that small then this is not the way to test. There is a great section on this in the book 4 Hour Work Week.
Although chrisacky flagged up some major issues in security above, there is more than one server/ domain running the system which they didn't discover. Once there is around 50 users on a server / domain I've created a new one.So thankfully chrisacky only managed to discover a small amount of users active on the service currently.