News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What's the future of software testing and QA? by nishilpatel on Monday January 05, 2026 @11:17AM (#46500603)
I agree with the core point: the more pure and deterministic a system is, the easier it is to reason about and test. Reducers + property-based testing push correctness into design, not brittle test cases.

One nuance though: property-based testing shines when the domain is already well-modeled. A lot of real QA pain comes where purity breaks down—distributed systems, async flows, partial failures, UI↔backend boundaries. At that point, the hard part isn’t generating tests, it’s reconstructing context.

On LLMs: I don’t think they should be trusted as correctness oracles either. Their real value isn’t guessing answers, but helping surface assumptions, generate counter-examples, and expose gaps in our mental model.

So the future of QA isn’t humans vs LLMs. It’s better system design + explicit invariants + tools that help engineers doubt their own certainty faster. Most serious bugs come from being sure we understood the system when we didn’t.

There are no comments on this comment yet.