News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unmasking The Biggest Troll on Reddit by klodolph on Saturday October 13, 2012 @12:18AM (#4647876)
> So Adrian Chen is creeped out by a legal behavior

This is a conflation of "illegal behavior" with "creepy behavior", but they are distinct categories.

> there are whole industries [...] that thrive doing exactly this to 16 year old girls.

It is not relevant that other people engage in similar behavior.

> So Adrian Chen is creeped out by a legal behavior and decides to defame someone

Defamation need not be false. (If it were false you could call it "slander" or "libel".) Again, this is conflation of illegal behavior with creepy behavior; there are lots of legal creepy things and lots of illegal things that aren't creepy.

> entirely fictional guilt (since there's no crime)

Conflation of meanings of the word guilt, which has a legal definition as well as a common definition. I could be "guilty" of standing a girl up on a date even though it's perfectly legal to do so.

Re:Unmasking The Biggest Troll on Reddit by gilgoomesh on Saturday October 13, 2012 @04:00AM (#4648167)
I accept your criticism that I've conflated legality with Chen's personal morality.

However, I think Chen has taken this action because he thinks violentacrez was objectively and unambiguous immoral -- which I think is not a univerally agreed point. I think alternative moral perspectives are indicated by the legal boundaries and the behaviors of other exploititative industries. I think this indicates that different moral standards on this issue are tolerated, even if they're still actively campaigned against.

I do now feel weird for defending ephebophiles.