News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by weinzierl on Friday January 02, 2026 @11:04AM (#46466134)
"Don't use Topaz AI, Anime4k, RealESRGAN, RIFE, etc. Trust me, just don't."

Why? I only know Topaz and I always thought it had its narrow but legitimate uses cases for upscaling and equalizing quality?

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by perching_aix on Friday January 02, 2026 @11:19AM (#46466303)
Can't mind read the guy obviously, but the usual motivation that I'm aware of is that you pretty much fuck over everyone else that comes later. Upscalers improve over time, but in terms of distribution, recency bias is strong and visual treats are inviting. So when those much better upscalers eventually come around, what's more likely to still be available is the secondary source you distributed, which is already upscaled once with a then-inferior upscaler. This leads to a form of generational rot.

Other likely explanations are:

- them not liking how these upscalers look: you can imagine if they can nitpick minor differences between different encodes that most people don't notice, they'll hate the glaring artifacts these filters usually produce

- boycotting AI

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by chrisldgk on Saturday January 03, 2026 @11:13AM (#46478307)
You should read the article.

The reasons stated against upscaling were that (re-)encoding video files should generally be done in a way that preserves as much of the original information and intent as possible. AI upscalers add information where there is none, thus modifying the video in a way that goes against that goal.

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by ErroneousBosh on Friday January 02, 2026 @11:32AM (#46466457)
Topaz looks bloody awful. Instead of big blocky upscaled pixels you've got weird artifacty "oil painting effect" smeary blobs.
Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by echelon on Friday January 02, 2026 @11:09AM (#46466185)
If someone has anti-AI opinions and spends zero effort explaining their position, I assume they have "AI Derangement" [1], a hate/fear perpetrated by the Big Scare media and podcasters seeking like/subscribes.

You can spend a tremendous amount of time using these tools to accomplish pretty stunning results already:

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tii9uF0nAx4 - Made by a film school grad as a demo of real filmmaking combined with AI VFX.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAQWRBCt_5E - Created by a Hollywood TV writer for an FX show you've probably seen. Not the best animation or voicing, but you can see how it gives a writer more than just a blank page to convey their thoughts.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWZYP5jn5w4 - Music video. Slightly MAGA-coded, but made by a Hollywood VFX person.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAAiiKteM-U - Made by a film school grad as a Robot Chicken homage. If you're going to tell them "don't use AI", then are you going to get them a job at Disney? Also, all the pieces are hand-rotoscoped, the mouth animations are hand-animated, and every voice is from a hired (and paid) voice actor.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4NFXGMuwpY - Made by a film school grad as a Robot Chicken homage. See previous comment.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_KXYpaTe_8 - Another slightly MAGA-coded music video. Made by the same Hollywood VFX person.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hlx5Rslrzk - Amazing Spider-Man vs. Carnage anime created with ComfyUI and other models.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqoCWdOwr2U - Christmas Grinch anime.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKYeDIiqiHs - Totally 100% cursed. Made by a teenager following the comic book's plot. Instead of this teenager spending 100 hours on Fortnite, they made this.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ps5Dhc3Lh8U - A Pixar-like short film

[1] Creators and artists using AI have been harassed, doxxed, sent death threats, name-called, sent shock images, etc. by anti-AI folks at such volume, that we've become bitter about these people. This is literally just a new tool in the tool box. We shouldn't be treated like this.

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by cnntth on Friday January 02, 2026 @11:24AM (#46466375)
OP makes zero comments about content generation, and the complaint is about upscaling introducing artifacts not in the original source. No different than hating a bad 4k remaster / sharpening.
Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by echelon on Friday January 02, 2026 @12:00PM (#46466790)
That advice is not universal, and without context it's simply wrong.

You wouldn't upscale a classic film in this way, but there are plenty of low-resolution shots that benefit. Especially with VGA resolution renders and modern AI workflows.

Just looking at the Topaz marketing, you can see a lot of places where it indeed does work. And 20-year industry professionals are using it today for their day jobs.

If you want to say "don't upscale a classic film in Topaz", say that. Because context makes the advice correct. This blanket "do not use" statement is flat out wrong.

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by unloader6118 on Friday January 02, 2026 @12:53PM (#46467411)
In any case, blindly apply upscaling is just wrong ..

You apply it to where it is needed. Not every scene need the same treatment.

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by echelon on Friday January 02, 2026 @01:42PM (#46467926)
The article simply says "Trust me, just don't."
Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by littlestymaar on Friday January 02, 2026 @03:19PM (#46468922)
No it doesn't. It says “don't, Unless you're extremely surgical with it and know exactly what you're doing”.

Which is a sensible piece of advice.

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by embedding-shape on Friday January 02, 2026 @03:48PM (#46469173)
> Don't use Topaz AI, Anime4k, RealESRGAN, RIFE, etc. Trust me, just don't.

Is what the submission says about Topaz and similar.

> Applying any kind of post-processing[4]

Is what the footnote you quoted is linked to.

Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by littlestymaar on Friday January 02, 2026 @06:36PM (#46470869)
There's no mistake, “Topaz and similar” == “any kind of postprocessing”.
Re:What You Need to Know Before Touching a Video File by embedding-shape on Saturday January 03, 2026 @05:32AM (#46475026)
Right, but since the "AI upscaling" "advice" is more specific, doesn't that take precedent?

> Do post-processing if you're surgical about it

> Don't do AI upscaling regardless, never do it, and don't even ask why

Is the impression I get from this article.