News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Bezos: We don't make any money on Kindle by Millennium on Friday October 12, 2012 @09:41AM (#4644961)
Couldn't that be considered predatory?
Re:Amazon's Bezos: We don't make any money on Kindle by JackC on Friday October 12, 2012 @10:02AM (#4645049)
So first of all, it doesn't say they're selling it below cost, and they are engaged in an overall razor-and-blade strategy that is profitable without the need to drive competitors out of the market. So factually, maybe not predatory.

In general, you would have to prove that Amazon has so much power in the market, and the market is so hard to enter, that they are likely to recover their losses from low prices now by charging higher-than-competitive prices later, without competitors coming in and undercutting them when they change strategies. Otherwise low prices are good for consumers and antitrust has nothing to say about it.

That said, Amazon already has a ton of power over book publishers, and they are trying hard to extend that power. If I were an antitrust regulator, I'd be trying like hell to make a case against them. But it would be tricky.

Re:Amazon's Bezos: We don't make any money on Kindle by lionhearted on Friday October 12, 2012 @09:58AM (#4645037)
I voted you up, but I don't think so. Some worthwhile pieces to read and contrast --

Loss leaders (common to almost all retailers):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader

The razor-and-blades business model, made famous by Gillette:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freebie_marketing

Compare that to predatory pricing --

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing

Predatory pricing is most possible when a large profit systems-based company can run a loss in one area to destroy competitors to the system. For instance, British Airway cutting rates on a New York <-> London flight to very cheap if a new carrier emerges to challenge them, even losing money on the route while having the rest of the airline subsidize them.

It'd be possible in air travel, because the gains are potentially huge. Airline seats are incredibly perishable, so the additional revenue from flying with a more full plane is very worth running short-term losses to get, and by keeping the general route fares high it could help them a lot. Also, because there's limited airline landing slots, they won't necessarily face constant competition -- if the competitor goes bust and someone like BA can buy their airport slots, they've further entrenched their position against future challengers in multiple ways -- they've got the landing slots, and financiers saw the previous company go bust, making it more difficult to get capital.

How does that differ from razors-and-blades or loss leading? I think it comes down to intent. Discounting, taking no gain, or even a small loss to win a consumer's attention and business seems worthy, especially when developing new markets. Discounting strictly to destroy competition, with the intent of raising prices very quickly after the competition goes bust -- that's more out of line. A quick acid test might be, "Would this be a viably pursued strategy if there was no competition?"

And with legitimate loss-leading, you could say yes. Someone will go to a liquor store more off if there's a cheap decent beer or wine on sale, regardless of competition in the area. People would potentially buy more disposable razors if the initial package of working razor comes in at a cheap price point, so it's easy for new people to try it out. Likewise, the Kindle.

All of these strategies establish market positions and gain market share, which is obviously somewhat to the potential detriment of would-be competitors (...well, unless it grows the market more than grabs market share...) -- but loss leading or razors-and-blades seems to focus more on attracting the consumer than bankrupting the competition.

Re:Amazon's Bezos: We don't make any money on Kindle by huxley on Friday October 12, 2012 @10:25AM (#4645147)
Just to correct your "razor-and-blades business model, made famous by Gillette" comment, Gillette never did that (which the wikipedia article alludes to).

While the blades were very high-margin, Gillette razors were quite expensive, about $150 in current dollars.

Re:Amazon's Bezos: We don't make any money on Kindle by wtvanhest on Friday October 12, 2012 @10:48AM (#4645235)
They sent me a free razor when I turned 18 and they have been charging me ridiculously high prices for the blades ever since.
Re:Amazon's Bezos: We don't make any money on Kindle by huxley on Friday October 12, 2012 @11:36AM (#4645460)
That's a relatively recent marketing campaign (unless you're 130 years old). When people talk about "razor-and-blades" freebie marketing it refers to the early-20th century razor market:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freebie_marketing#Gillette