Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by nine_k on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:17AM
(#46445463)
Sequestering CO2 where it's highly concentrated, e.g. at power plants or cement factories exhausts, would be one way to emit less.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by LargeWu on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:40AM
(#46445699)
I've wondered if capturing carbon emissions from industrial-scale compost facilities would be a net positive. It would have the added benefit of the carbon initially being captured by natural organic processes (i.e. growing food), so it avoids the problem of the energy requirements from trying to just pull carbon from the ambient atmosphere. I don't know if this is feasible but I haven't seen any research on it.
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by nine_k on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:47AM
(#46445782)
What we need to offset the last 3 centuries of coal use is to reverse the process. Plant large amounts of trees, cut them, burn the hydrogen part of them, producing char and reclaiming some energy, then bury the resulting coal back in the abandoned coal mines.
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by LargeWu on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @12:10PM
(#46445994)
Yeah, that too. There's not going to be one single solution, the problem is just too big for that. The idea with compost is that growing plants for food and dealing with the waste and excess (which is substantial) is something we're already doing, so can we tack carbon sequestration on top of that
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by mikestorrent on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @12:51PM
(#46446464)
> burn the hydrogen part of them
Could you elaborate
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by fodkodrasz on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @02:43PM
(#46447567)
I guess Coke.
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by mikestorrent on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @03:09PM
(#46447792)
How are we getting that out of a tree
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by nine_k on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @05:53PM
(#46449203)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charcoal
Did you ever do a barbecue? You first burn the light, hydrogen-rich substances of the firewood, with a large beautiful flame; that flame would burn down the meat, but it burns off quickly. What remains is charcoal, the source of most heat in the firewood; it does no produce a visible flame, but emits a lot of heat. It is mostly carbon.
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by oneshtein on Thursday January 01, 2026 @12:42AM
(#46451626)
Make char coal and store it underground.
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by TSiege on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @12:56PM
(#46446528)
This is called Carbon Capture and Storage and so far it has never been worth it energetically. And the only companies doing it are oil companies in a process known as enhanced recovery which pushes more co2 out than is pushed in. The OP was right. Better to leave it in the ground
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by nine_k on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @05:49PM
(#46449174)
You can have 100% renewable energy. You can't realistically produce cement or steel without using and exhausting large amounts of CO2. This has to be addressed, even if it costs energy (which, as we agreed, can be 100% carbon-neutral).
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by adgjlsfhk1 on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @07:21PM
(#46449838)
there is no world in which it is cheaper to produce steel releasing CO2 and recapturing than fobbing off recapture until later. the thermodynamics just don't work.
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by Thorrez on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:14AM
(#46453189)
Sorry, I don't understand. You're comparing 2 things. For the 2nd thing, are you including the cost of later recapture or not?
If you're not including the cost of later recapture, then it's not a fair comparison.
If you are including the cost of later recapture, why is it cheaper to recapture later than to do so immediately?
Re:Efficient method to capture CO2 from the atmosphere / Uni...
by teknopaul on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @12:59PM
(#46446553)
I think OPs point is this tech is good only if you sink it after.
I. e. Collection is half the problem.
Collecting it in a way it's cheap to get it back again is potentially just less than minus half the problem.