There is an opt-out link on instapaper's publishers page at http://www.instapaper.com/publishers
If publishers don't like being scraped by instapaper they can opt-out. So far it looks like "no major publishers" have.
Re:The Magazine launch day FAQ
by Kylekramer on Thursday October 11, 2012 @06:56PM
(#4643190)
As I duly noted in my original comment. Once again, defaults matter.
I'd be more impressed if he did allow sharing to competitors and let Instapaper win on quality, not a hard coded restriction. It would show a remarkable faith in his product.