Re:Toll roads are spreading in America
by potato3732842 on Sunday December 28, 2025 @09:19AM
(#46411234)
That sort of stuff makes for great fantasy for people who fancy themselves central planners but back in the real world it flied in the face of the principals of a) punishment fitting the crime b) justice being blind-ish, which "real society" values far more than internet comment sections would have you believe.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Toll roads are spreading in America
by harimau777 on Sunday December 28, 2025 @12:19PM
(#46412616)
I disagree. Not charging a rich person enough to incentivize them to change means that the punishment doesn't fit the crime for them. Similarly, charging people a fine proportionate to their wealth is much more just than a fine that is devistating for the poor but insignificant for the rich.
Re:Toll roads are spreading in America
by pfannkuchen on Sunday December 28, 2025 @01:22PM
(#46413212)
I’m generally not a lefty type person, but aren’t resource agnostic fines actually less blind-justice than the alternative?
The wealthy speeder shrugs it off, while the poor speeder has to change their spending allocation in a way that is noticeable and could be challenging.
Why should the punishment have a different impact based on wealth? The felt impact of a monetary fine fundamentally depends on how much money the offender has. Whereas the classic “locked in a cage” punishment affects everyone equally.