News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple releases open-source model that instantly turns 2D ... by _flux on Saturday December 27, 2025 @12:19PM (#46403325)
> Open source means the source is available. Anything else is just political.

Where was that defined so? And most of all, given the domain of information technology, who understand open source to cover cases where the source is available ie. only for reviewing?

The purpose of words and terms is so that people can exchange ideas effectively and precisely, without needing to explain the terms every time from the grounds up. Having different groups having divergent definitions on the same words is counterproductive towards that goal. In my view, labeling a release "open source" with very big limitations on how the source is used is just not about marketing, it's miscommunication.

If "open source" and "source available" (and "open weights") mean the same thing, the how come people have come up with the two terms to begin with? The difference is recognized in official contexts as well, i.e. https://web.archive.org/web/20180724032116/https://dodcio.de... (search for "source available"; unfortunately linking directly doesn't seem to work with archive.org pages).

It doesn't seem there is any benefit in using less precise terms when better-defined ones are available.

Re:Apple releases open-source model that instantly turns 2D ... by ecb_penguin on Saturday December 27, 2025 @12:54PM (#46403655)
> Where was that defined so?

Anything more than the definition is extra. In this case it's political. That doesn't require a definition.

> The purpose of words and terms is so that people can exchange ideas effectively and precisely, without needing to explain the terms every time from the grounds up.

Do you think the 10 criteria of a non-profit's opinion effectively conveys information without needing to explain the terms from the ground up?

> Having different groups having divergent definitions on the same words is counterproductive

Right, which is why the parent is wrong. It's just an organization's opinion

> If "open source" and "source available" (and "open weights") mean the same thing

They don't mean the same thing and I never claimed they do.

> It doesn't seem there is any benefit in using less precise terms when better-defined ones are available.

Use the more precise terms then. But you can't say the definition of open source is this 10 points of criteria that people disagree about....