News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alzheimer's can be reversed to achieve full neurological ... by reissbaker on Thursday December 25, 2025 @03:02PM (#46386703)
Sadly, it's worse. We don't have one experiment that works in mice: we have dozens, if not hundreds. We've cured "Alzheimer's in mice" many times over. The treatments never work in humans, because it's not the same disease. We don't know the root cause of the human disease and so we can't model it accurately in mice.
Re:Alzheimer's can be reversed to achieve full neurological ... by everdrive on Thursday December 25, 2025 @03:42PM (#46386912)
I totally get that people are not mice, however animals studies have been useful for all sorts of diseases. Are they really uniquely bad for Alzheimer's?
Re:Alzheimer's can be reversed to achieve full neurological ... by adinb on Thursday December 25, 2025 @04:44PM (#46387236)
No. I believe the problem is with our artificial models of Alzheimer’s in mice.
Re:Alzheimer's can be reversed to achieve full neurological ... by greygoo222 on Thursday December 25, 2025 @04:46PM (#46387245)
To put it simply, mice don't get Alzheimer's. We're not studying mice with Alzheimer's, we're studying mice with an mutation chosen for resembling Alzheimer's. But we don't know whether this model replicates the actual mechanisms of the disease, or if it's superficial.
Re:Alzheimer's can be reversed to achieve full neurological ... by everdrive on Friday December 26, 2025 @06:51AM (#46391254)
Thanks for the explanation, this really clears up the concerns here. It's easy to imagine scientists attempting to model in in mice and making real progress, but it's also easy to imagine us misunderstanding the real disease well enough such that what we've modeled in mice does not produce real results.
Re:Alzheimer's can be reversed to achieve full neurological ... by esperent on Thursday December 25, 2025 @10:25PM (#46388936)
> We don't know the root cause of the human disease

It's increasingly likely that there is no "root cause" to find in humans, but rather, that Alzheimer's is what happens when there's enough external stressors acting on the brain.

I've seen an analogy of a leaky roof being used: the leaks are things like age, stress, heavy metals, mold, bad sleep, bad diet. Genetics defines the original building materials (resilience) of the roof. You can put buckets under a certain number of leaks but if there are too many your ability to repair gets overwhelmed and the result is diseases like dementia.

I think something similar applies to other diseases of aging like heart disease, arthritis, osteoporosis, diabetes, perhaps even cancer.

The downside of this is that's it's hard to imagine a miracle drug being the solution. But the upside is that a combination therapy that identifies the "leaks" and works on reducing or eliminating them will likely be effective against a wide range of age related diseases.

The therapy will likely consist of drugs and supplements in combination with lifestyle changes.