I don't believe that you got a call from Marc Andreessen to organize a moderation approach that benefits them. Instead I believe that your blind spots created moderation decisions that limited discourse. And it worries me that the reaction is to complain about kafkaesque logic.
Headlines are important. And given that HN has a policy of moderators editing headlines it is really important that mods do a very good job not distorting headlines. This means that your evaluation of the importance of each word in the headline is really important. It concerned me that in your mind the reference to a16z was the least important material in the headline when I suspect that a typical HN participant would see it as among the most important material in the headline.
The title change was consistent with the guidelines, which it’s my job to uphold. Then I changed it when the community made its feelings known.
You’ve continued with the unfalsifiable claims while avoiding the one question that matters:
How does it materially benefit an outside VC firm if the title on an HN post about one of their portfolio companies excludes their name? What is the tangible economic impact?
What does this mean? Why would a VC firm like this "corrupt" HN and how would they to it?
> Like it or not as an editor at HN you're in a position of power and influence
I think dang has written about this plenty [1]; he certainly talked about it in the article in The New Yorker; it's a myth that the moderators have great power and influence. The community has the power here. I wouldn't/couldn't be doing this job if hadn't learned that a long time ago. The only thing anyone at A16Z has ever done to try and influence HN is to refer to it as “Hater News” [3][4], which really just goes to show how much they feel like they have no control over it. Which is exactly what we want and like. Nobody controls HN other than the HN community, and those of us who work on it know that we can only succeed at this if we act in the way that the community wants and expects of us every day.
[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
[2] https://archive.is/ybxFT
[3] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
[4] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1766448000&dateRange=custom&...