Re:“Nones” on the Rise: One-in-Five U.S. Adults Have No Reli...
by zwieback on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @04:21PM
(#4633725)
First you say the religious aspect of communities is coincidental then you say that religion forms chasm-surrounded communities.
Which is it?
Re:“Nones” on the Rise: One-in-Five U.S. Adults Have No Reli...
by lutusp on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @06:17PM
(#4634230)
> First you say the religious aspect of communities is coincidental then you say that religion forms chasm-surrounded communities. Which is it?
The dichotomy you think you see doesn't exist. They're both true.
Let me spell it out for you:
* The fact that many human communities are religious is a coincidence, an accident of history.
* Those religions that do form, tend to isolate themselves from other communities, sometimes by trying to convert or kill everyone they meet. This doesn't prevent them from being a community, any more than a community of rattlesnakes is not a legitimate community solely on the ground that it's dangerous to surrounding communities.
Clear now?
With all respect, the religious aspect of a human community is a coincidence -- on can have a community without the religious context. I personally think it's an unfortunate accident of history that so many human communities are built on a scaffolding of religion.
> It can also help bridge gaps between different parts of our society.
It is here that you touch an important point, indeed a critical one. History shows us that, overall, religion creates gaps, it doesn't mend them. For each religious endeavor to reach across a chasm between people, there are ten religious endeavors to create the chasm in the first place.