Re:Trained LLMs exclusively on pre-1913 texts
by patapong on Friday December 19, 2025 @08:10AM
(#46325423)
I think it's more likely they are terrified of someone making a prompt that gets the model to say something racist or problematic (which shouldn't be too hard), and the backlash they could receive as a result of that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Trained LLMs exclusively on pre-1913 texts
by p-e-w on Friday December 19, 2025 @08:12AM
(#46325444)
Is there anyone with a spine left in science? Or are they all ruled by fear of what might be said if whatever might happen?
Re:Trained LLMs exclusively on pre-1913 texts
by ACCount37 on Friday December 19, 2025 @09:24AM
(#46326171)
Selection effects. If showing that you have a spine means getting growth opportunities denied to you, and not paying lip service to current politics in grant applications means not getting grants, then anyone with a spine would tend to leave the field behind.
Re:Trained LLMs exclusively on pre-1913 texts
by paddleon on Friday December 19, 2025 @09:32AM
(#46326264)
maybe they are concerned by the widespread adoption of the attitude you are taking-- make a very strong accusation, then when it was pointed out that the accusation might be off base, continue to attack.
This constant demonization of everyone who disagrees with you, makes me wonder if 28 Days wasn't more true than we thought, we are all turning into rage zombies.
p-e-w, I'm reacting to much more than your comments. Maybe you aren't totally infected yet, who knows. Maybe you heal.
I am reacting to the pandemic, of which you were demonstrating symptoms.
Re:Trained LLMs exclusively on pre-1913 texts
by isolli on Friday December 19, 2025 @10:30AM
(#46326872)
Is it a base model, or did it get some RLHF on top? Releasing a base model is always dangerous.
The French released a preview of an AI meant to support public education, but they released the base model, with unsurprising effects [0]
[0] https://www.leparisien.fr/high-tech/inutile-et-stupide-lia-g...
(no English source, unfortunately, but the title translates as: "“Useless and stupid”: French generative AI Lucie, backed by the government, mocked for its numerous bugs")