News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by fasbiner on Friday December 19, 2025 @02:01AM (#46322991)
People pay the mafia protection money because it's cheaper than fighting the mob and it makes the mob go away for awhile, and in the long run, we're all dead. Most mafia-like entities don't have an inexorable existential drive to take it all, they just charge what the market will bear.

And if you think there's a definitional difference between a government, a corporation and a mafia that stands up to any objective measure and isn't based entirely on social cues and special pleading, I think that's an extraordinary claim you have no evidence for.

Go lead a maoist insurgency or don't, but the fingerwagging moral appeal is worse than useless.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by rightbyte on Friday December 19, 2025 @02:10AM (#46323042)
That seems rather reductionist.
Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by fasbiner on Friday December 19, 2025 @03:54AM (#46323692)
How so? In china, app stores are open to market competition as an eventual consequence of a maoist insurgency.

It's fine if you're personally a coward or you just don't think it's worth it. But not only does it work, it is so far, the only thing that has ever been proven to work.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by rightbyte on Friday December 19, 2025 @06:43AM (#46324743)
I am not a maoist.

I meant that this is reductionist:

> definitional difference between a government, a corporation and a mafia that stands up to any objective measure and isn't based entirely on social cues and special pleading

Thinking about it. Your post now is also reductionist. Maybe that is your thing?

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by fasbiner on Saturday December 20, 2025 @08:10PM (#46341290)
Using -ist instead of engaging in discussion or presenting any evidence or explanation whatsoever for extradorinaiy claims is in fact a thought-terminating cliche.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_clich%C3%A...

If I were to stoop to your level of reasoning and inquiry, I could simply say that you are are a racist and a sexist for disagreeing with me with just as much basis.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by bigyabai on Friday December 19, 2025 @02:09AM (#46323036)
> and in the long run, we're all dead.

Well gee, when you put it like that all morality is relative huh?

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by rcMgD2BwE72F on Friday December 19, 2025 @03:15AM (#46323466)
Of course morality is relative. But still, there's no point to compare something to nothing and say "why bother". Comparisons can be useful.
Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by b112 on Friday December 19, 2025 @07:38AM (#46325165)
Only a left or right, one or the other world view would think such.

As with almost everything, it's both. Some morality is relative, some is absolute.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by coldtea on Friday December 19, 2025 @08:01AM (#46325342)
What morality is absolute?

Morality being absolute means just that you subjectively consider some moral rules absolute. Doesn't make them so, the way the law of gravity is absolute.

And it doesn't mean that every human society agrees to what you consider "absolute".

All things you consider "absolute", there are whole societies which found them to be just fine, and you'd do too if you were raised in them, including incest, murder of innocents, slavery, torture...

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by somenameforme on Friday December 19, 2025 @08:17AM (#46325481)
Many things are naturally repulsive, but are indulged out of necessity or gain. For instance Aristotle wasn't opposed to slavery, yet nonetheless in his writings, now some 2400+ years ago, he found himself obligated to lay out an extensive and lengthy defense and rationalization of such, and he even predicted what would eventually end it:

"For if every instrument could accomplish its own work, obeying or anticipating the will of others, like the statues of Daedalus, or the tripods of Hephaestus, which, says the poet, 'Of their own accord entered the assembly of the Gods.' If, in like manner, the shuttle would weave and the plectrum touch the lyre without a hand to guide them, chief workmen would not want servants, nor masters slaves." [1]

There were millennia of efforts to end slavery, but it's only the technological and industrial revolution that finally succeeded in doing so. But the point is that even though Aristotle was ostensibly not opposed to slavery, he nonetheless knew it was a decision that needed justification because it was fundamentally repulsive, even in a society where it was ubiquitous and relatively non-controversial, thousands of years ago.

This 'natural repulsion' is, I think, some degree of evidence for persistent, if not absolute, morality throughout at least thousands of years of humanity's existence, and I see no reason to assume it would not trend back long further than that.

[1] - https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/politics.mb.txt

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by coldtea on Friday December 19, 2025 @09:35AM (#46326300)
>Many things are naturally repulsive, but are indulged out of necessity or gain

Most "naturally repulsive" things were accepted just fine in one society or another.

Aristole spent time to defend and rationalize slavery because that was just job, to spend time rationalizing things. Other societies practiced it with no such worries, and found it perfectly natural.

But even if we grant you your "naturally repulsive" actions existing, it doesn't mean they are objectively morally wrong. Just that their moral judgement is not just based on culture and historical period, but also on evolutionary adaptations. These could very well be considered fine in an earlier/later evolutionary stage (in an earlier one, for sure: animals don't have such qualms).

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by somenameforme on Friday December 19, 2025 @12:22PM (#46328360)
His arguments were generally driven by logic and reason, not rationalization. Rationalization is generally only necessary for adopting views that seem ostensibly inappropriate, which would certainly include these sort of 'naturally repulsive' acts. And indeed his arguments for slavery were some of his weakest precisely because they were uncharacteristic rationalizations.

I completely agree that if you go back far enough in the evolutionary pipeline then my claim becomes invalid. I also think it would not apply to people of a sufficiently reduced IQ. You need to have a minimum of intelligence to understand what you're doing, alternatives, and its consequences on others. But once you have that baseline of IQ then I think morality, and a natural repulsion to certain behaviors, comes as naturally as communication.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by coldtea on Friday December 19, 2025 @02:28PM (#46329842)
>His arguments were generally driven by logic and reason, not rationalization. Rationalization is generally only necessary for adopting views that seem ostensibly inappropriate, which would certainly include these sort of 'naturally repulsive' acts.

I think that's an after-the-fact assessment of what his treatment of the subject was, which we arrive at because of our modern morals.

In his time he, and his audience, didn't think of it as rationalization, but as legitimate use of logic and reason, just like his treatment of other topics.

>But once you have that baseline of IQ then I think morality, and a natural repulsion to certain behaviors, comes as naturally as communication.

Might go the over way around too though: once you go above a certain IQ, it might be easier to treat morality as a fiction naked apes developed, as opposed to something objective, and even discard it entirely.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by somenameforme on Saturday December 20, 2025 @12:20AM (#46333812)
No, his arguments were materially different in this case. Most of his arguments came from first principles and worked outwards from some baseline; in particular - what is virtue and how virtue, itself, leads to satisfaction in life, and onward to how this can apply to systems and politics in general. But slavery he treated in an entirely different, practically ad hoc, fashion starting from slavery and then trying to shoe-horn in a justification along the lines of what you alluded to already with e.g. natural order and it being an inescapable inevitability.

It was a complete, and poor, rationalization. He even added, almost as a disclaimer, that there was not a complete overlap between 'natural' slaves and legal slaves, giving himself a plausible out to explain the endless examples of the repulsiveness of the institution by applying a no true scotmans fallacy, 'Ahh yes, I would agree with you there. But that is because that is not a natural slave, but merely a legal one.' And this is not my opinion alone. It has long been considered notably weak, especially from an otherwise brilliant man.

And I think that leads into your next issue. I don't think higher intelligence makes it easier to treat morality as a fiction, but rather even average intelligence, without discipline and virtue, makes it very easy to engage in self delusion and cognitive dissonance. Even those conditions are hardly a guarantee - Aristotle certainly had and strived for both discipline and virtue, yet the desire to rationalize what we want to be true, even if we know it is not, is a never-ending struggle that's easy to fail.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by coldtea on Friday December 19, 2025 @07:59AM (#46325324)
Morality is all relative any way you put it. There's no God-given objective morality, it's human made and changes.
Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by bigyabai on Friday December 19, 2025 @02:00PM (#46329546)
Okay, but treating "being dead" and "demanding higher standards of living" as morally consistent is too facetious to be relevant.
Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by ben_w on Friday December 19, 2025 @04:48AM (#46323992)
> People pay the mafia protection money because it's cheaper than fighting the mob and it makes the mob go away for awhile, and in the long run, we're all dead. Most mafia-like entities don't have an inexorable existential drive to take it all, they just charge what the market will bear.

If I had to guess, the Mafia will have professional economists on payroll telling the bosses about the Laffer curve and emigration.

But in this context, Apple's clearly on the low end of the Laffer curve* because they don't need a million apps, so who cares if the store fees are 15% or 85%, the supply is still there?**; while for emigration, being the least bad of the Apple/Google duopoly is all that is necessary.

* if you take literally that the App store fee is the "Apple tax"

** Answer: Judges in market abuse/monopoly cases because Apple is not actually sovereign; on paper neither is the Mafia, but this is where "monopoly on violence" is a useful definition of a state, in that where anything like the Mafia can exist, the state is de facto not sovereign no matter what it says on paper.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by coldtea on Friday December 19, 2025 @07:57AM (#46325305)
>And if you think there's a definitional difference between a government, a corporation and a mafia that stands up to any objective measure and isn't based entirely on social cues and special pleading,

If we're speaking of democratic governments you usually get to vote (whatever ineffective). And if we're speaking for non monopolistic corporations you also get to buy from another. With mafia there's a single, non-negotiable, option: the one running your area.

And both for goverments and corporations, there are other parties (e.g. courts) limiting what they can do.

Re:2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity i... by Imustaskforhelp on Friday December 19, 2025 @01:05PM (#46328886)
To be honest the parent's comment which related to mafia was already a bit streched but comparing it to maoist insurgency feels like the extreme of an extreme.

Can we please discuss how this comment is relevant to the Apple's discussion and how it fits in perhaps too.