Re:Gut Bacteria from Amphibians and Reptiles Achieve Complet...
by d--b on Thursday December 18, 2025 @08:11AM
(#46312190)
If it is the case that there are such treatments (easy to produce, 100% efficacy, no side effect) that cure fairly common deadly disease such as colorectal cancer in mice, and that never make it to human trial, there is something seriously broken about medical research...
Re:Gut Bacteria from Amphibians and Reptiles Achieve Complet...
by estearum on Thursday December 18, 2025 @10:01AM
(#46313391)
No, the issue is that mice are very different from humans.
The only thing such a state of affairs clearly indicates is broken is using mice as proto-human test subjects.
Which of course, when you state it like that, is obviously suboptimal. But no one knows what to do about it.
Re:Gut Bacteria from Amphibians and Reptiles Achieve Complet...
by gus_massa on Thursday December 18, 2025 @12:15PM
(#46315585)
Mice are good because they are super cheap.
It's useful as a very early test. They used a shotgun approach, they tested 9 bacterias and 1 of them was suspenseful. At least it was suspenseful for 2 weeks, until the study ended. It's very difficult to extrapolate that to the 5 year survival rate in humans.
Re:Gut Bacteria from Amphibians and Reptiles Achieve Complet...
by estearum on Thursday December 18, 2025 @01:55PM
(#46316909)
Correct, this is how drug development works.
Re:Gut Bacteria from Amphibians and Reptiles Achieve Complet...
by d--b on Thursday December 18, 2025 @11:10AM
(#46314515)
Right, yes, at least that study proved that some bacteria eat cancerous cells in at least one mammal.
If that particular bacteria doesn't work in humans it may still trigger a search for a bacteria that does.
Still being optimistic about this :)
I wouldn't describe it working in humans as "a stretch" per se. I'm not identifying a specific reason it shouldn't work in humans. I'm just saying that's true of thousands and thousands of really great looking treatments (per year!) that, nonetheless, end up not working in humans, or not being convincing enough to even warrant putting them in humans once.