Re:The software development final exam: Computer Architectur...
by antidoh on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @07:40AM
(#4630973)
"What every pilot should know" might be a better analogy. Pilots are more directly responsible for keeping their vehicle within safe conditions, and to do that they need to know more about their vehicles than car drivers.
Programmers affect and determine the operation of the computers their code runs on much more than a driver driving inside the lines.
Re:The software development final exam: Computer Architectur...
by randomdata on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @07:59AM
(#4631018)
I really like the first analogy, actually. A driver who knows all the details of how each engine works will be able to choose the car that provides the best fuel economy and performance, but in the end, the driver's status will really only be judged on the style and features of the car they choose.
i.e. the developer who chooses the slower zeroarray algorithm that still completes in reasonable time, but provides a better user interface and better feature set is still the better software developer (but perhaps the poorer computer scientist).
Re:The software development final exam: Computer Architectur...
by kamaal on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @11:41PM
(#4634946)
I am pretty sure pilots don't master fluid mechanics in detail.
Re:The software development final exam: Computer Architectur...
by jrajav on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @07:51AM
(#4630992)
I'm excited and motivated to learn by these posts, and I can tell others feel the same way, but I share this sentiment. To me, it even seems a little too fair to compare it to drivers and mechanics. It's more like a pitch to drivers about how to be a better car mechanic, when the target demographic actually includes drivers, stock car drivers, car mechanics, automotive designers, motorcyclists, motorcycle mechanics, pilots, submarine engineers, rocket scientists...
Re:The software development final exam: Computer Architectur...
by Ensorceled on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @07:39AM
(#4630968)
I like that analogy but it's worse than you say:
2 of the questions are about drift racing (mutexs) 2 of the questions are about the design of the fuel injection control chip 1 question is a subtle question about the fuel injection control chip
Need a car analogy? Fine: you pitched this as "what every driver should know about driving", and you're talking about the intricacies of combustion engines. That is to say, it's interesting, may pin together some pieces of other knowledge, but of no real practical use to anyone who doesn't also fit in to the "and I'm a mechanic" demographic.