Re:A Unix Utility You Should Know About: Pipe Viewer
by palish on Monday February 02, 2009 @08:07PM
(#463274)
The term "self-reflection" dates back to 1652, so why change it?
I'm saying it shouldn't have been used in the first place. It's an awkward, confusing metaphor. Programs aren't "reflecting", because "self-reflection" is something that only a sentient creature can perform. Programs currently have no concept of "self". I'd say "reflection" is less accurate than "type information", which covers at least 95% of use cases, if not more.
I don't think concepts should be misnamed at the expense of accuracy.
Neither do I. Also, all else being equal, less metaphors are better.
Reflection is the ability of something to introspect. The term "self-reflection" dates back to 1652[1], so why change it? "Type information" is inaccurate because reflection can mean more than just getting information about types, like interfacing with the runtime or getting information about the language implementation.
I don't think concepts should be misnamed at the expense of accuracy.
[1] http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/self-reflection