News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by kevingadd on Monday October 08, 2012 @10:51PM (#4629686)
I think "external memories" is a reasonable term for this. If you treat it as an analogue to the computer science definition of memory - a place to store information - then it's a pretty decent way of describing what's happening here.

I suppose the fact that the information is being stored at the location it describes, instead of in a central location, makes it a bit weird?

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by jamesrcole on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @12:47AM (#4630001)
I suppose the fact that the information is being stored at the location it describes, instead of in a central location, makes it a bit weird?

"weird" is emotional response. I think that function is the appropriate criteria here. Functionally, it is serving as memory. There's no magic difference between inside the body and outside of it.

Richard Dawkins' The Extended Phenotype http://www.amazon.com/Extended-Phenotype-Reach-Popular-Scien... is a good read on this sort of stuff (it's a little bit more technical than his other books, but still readable by someone without a biology background).

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by Groxx on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @02:14AM (#4630241)
I'd be willing to bet the mold grows generally away from the most-dense areas (say, the interior of a glob). This makes sense energy wise - would you also call that "remembering" where it was?

Similarly, many plants "lean" to point towards the sun. Are they "remembering" where the sun is with the increased growth on the far side?

You can (successfully) argue that it can be an accurate description. It is. I would argue that it's deliberately choosing words that invoke more interest (be it scientific or "OMGWHAT") than accuracy.

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by jmmcd on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @07:05AM (#4630897)
> Similarly, many plants "lean" to point towards the sun. Are they "remembering" where the sun is with the increased growth on the far side?

If they had put the sun there first, then yeah, that would be external memory. That's the difference.

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by Groxx on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @12:15PM (#4632359)
No, plants which do this generally grow less on the sunny side of their stalk. They are putting more / larger cells on the far side, as a form of memory. A crude counting system, if you will - when side A > side B, side B is where the sun is. Arguably this is even more complex than a mere external memory system - it deals in continuous ratios, rather than booleans!
Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by jmmcd on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @02:22PM (#4633153)
Hmm. If you're just talking about the extra growth, then that's not even external. I don't think it's a good example.
Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by Groxx on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @03:48PM (#4633580)
Not of an external memory system, no. This would be internal. But would you call it "an internal memory system", or "decreased growth in reaction to sunlight"?

Another option: (micro-)evolution. Is an amoeba's resistance to a chemical "memory", or an environment-selected random mutation? Again, technically it can be viewed as memory, but it's diluting the term so far as to make it a catch-all for any kind of information, ever, to get someone to click on a link.

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by jmmcd on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @04:02PM (#4633644)
> But would you call it "an internal memory system"

Well, it's not being used later on to make decisions, is it?

I suppose I will go with that for my definition of memory: the agent makes a change to the state of the world (external) or to its own state (internal) and that change later affects its action.

Using that definition, my answer re the amoeba is yes.

I can see why it seems too broad. But I don't know a better definition. I suppose one could stipulate that consciousness is required. But I don't think that would be a standard position.

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by Groxx on Saturday October 13, 2012 @01:32PM (#4649090)
>Well, it's not being used later on to make decisions, is it?

No, you have a point there. I missed that part. Though I just realized your new definition implies this: a river has memory.

To each their own :) I'll still call it too broad, but that's pure opinion.

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by jmmcd on Sunday October 14, 2012 @05:41PM (#4652739)
> a river has memory

Nice point... well, I'm all ears for a better definition :)

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by pyre on Monday October 08, 2012 @11:25PM (#4629802)
How does one slime mold react to the 'slime' left by another?
Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by Lockyy on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @07:54AM (#4631000)
Unless the slime the researchers planted was from the slime-mold being experimented upon we can assume that they react in the same way to other slime-mold's slime as to their own.
Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by pyre on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @10:24AM (#4631634)
Can they really be said to be 'memories' then?

I doubt that most people would consider Hansel and Gretel's trail of breadcrumbs a form of 'external memory.'

Re:Organism without a brain creates external memories for na... by eyeface on Tuesday October 09, 2012 @10:59AM (#4631851)
Could you elaborate on what an 'external memory' would be then?